Read the following excerpt and answer the question.
"The United States Steel Corporation, capitalized at $1.4 billion, is the largest corporation in American history. It controls 60% of American steel production, 75% of iron ore reserves, and employs 168,000 workers. J.P. Morgan has assembled this combination from Carnegie Steel and dozens of smaller companies. Whether this represents the natural culmination of industrial capitalism's tendency toward concentration, or a dangerous monopoly requiring federal action, is the central question of the new century."
— Synthetic excerpt describing the formation of U.S. Steel, 1901
The question posed in this source most directly anticipated which of the following historical debates?
- AThe international trade debate over whether U.S. Steel's domestic monopoly gave American manufacturers an unfair pricing advantage abroad, prompting retaliatory tariffs
- BThe Progressive Era debate between the 'New Nationalism' (accepting bigness if regulated) and the 'New Freedom' (breaking up monopolies to restore competition) over industrial concentrationCorrect
- CThe labor movement's debate over whether to organize industry-wide industrial unions or maintain narrow craft unions, which left most U.S. Steel workers outside organized labor
- DThe constitutional debate over Congress's authority to regulate corporations under the commerce clause, which the Supreme Court would later resolve in favor of federal power
Why B is right
The question of 'natural culmination' vs. 'dangerous monopoly' is exactly the New Nationalism vs. New Freedom debate: Roosevelt (New Nationalism) accepted large corporations as efficient but wanted regulatory oversight; Wilson (New Freedom) wanted to break up monopolies and restore competition. This debate defined Progressive Era political economy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Trade retaliation concerns were not the primary issue raised by U.S. Steel's formation; the domestic monopoly power question dominated discussion.
- C
- While labor organizing in steel was important, the source's specific question is about whether concentration is natural/inevitable or problematic — an industrial organization question, not a labor strategy question.
- D
- While constitutional questions about federal regulatory authority were debated, the source's question is about whether federal action was warranted, not about its constitutional basis.