"The Cahokia site near present-day St. Louis reached its peak around 1100 CE, housing perhaps 20,000 people. At its center rose a massive earthen mound larger at its base than the Great Pyramid of Giza. The city controlled trade networks stretching from the Gulf Coast to the Great Lakes, exchanging copper, marine shells, and prestige goods."
— Modern archaeologist describing the Mississippian culture, c. 2015
The description of Cahokia most directly challenges which of the following historical assumptions?
- AThe argument that Mesoamerican civilizations like the Aztec and Maya were inherently more advanced than all North American societies because only they developed true writing systems
- BThe theory that every pre-Columbian North American people descended from a single migratory wave that crossed the Bering land bridge during the last Ice Age
- CThe belief that pre-Columbian North American societies were uniformly small, mobile, and lacked complex hierarchies or long-distance tradeCorrect
- DThe claim that European colonization accelerated the rise of urban centers in North America by introducing new agricultural techniques
Why C is right
The description of Cahokia directly challenges the Eurocentric assumption that pre-Columbian North America was inhabited only by small, nomadic, or semi-nomadic peoples without complex social organization. Cahokia's population of 20,000, monumental architecture (Monk's Mound), and extensive long-distance trade networks demonstrate sophisticated political hierarchy, specialized labor, surplus agriculture, and complex social organization well before European contact, contradicting the narrative of North American peoples as primitive or simple.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the description of Cahokia does not address writing systems, and a comparison with Mesoamerican civilizations is not what the source directly challenges; the challenge is to assumptions about North American complexity generally.
- B
- Incorrect because Cahokia's complexity does not address migration theories; the Bering land bridge theory remains the consensus explanation for the initial peopling of the Americas regardless of the complexity of later civilizations.
- D
- Incorrect because Cahokia flourished centuries before European contact, predating any possible European agricultural influence; the description actually demonstrates indigenous North American agricultural sophistication independent of Europe.