"They [the Tlaxcalans] are very intelligent people...and they told me that in former times they used to have many lords, and that as a result of many wars and much contention among themselves, Moctezuma had subjugated and made tributary all of them except the province of Tlaxcala."
—Hernán Cortés, letter to Charles V, 1520
Which of the following most directly contributed to the outcome described in this passage?
- AThe Catholic Church's missionary diplomacy, which persuaded Indigenous peoples across Mesoamerica to ally voluntarily with the Spanish crown
- BThe Aztec Empire's decision to negotiate peacefully with the Spanish invaders rather than mount sustained military resistance to them
- CThe technological superiority of Spanish firearms, which rendered any meaningful Tlaxcalan or Aztec military resistance impossible
- DPre-existing political rivalries within Mesoamerica that Cortés exploited to forge alliances against the Aztec EmpireCorrect
Why D is right
The Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire succeeded not through Spanish arms alone but through alliance-building. The Tlaxcalans, who resented Aztec dominance and tribute demands, became crucial allies of Cortés. This illustrates how pre-existing Indigenous political conflicts enabled Spanish conquest—a complexity often overlooked in accounts emphasizing only European military technology.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the Church's missionary role came later in the colonial period; the initial alliances were forged on political and military grounds, not religious persuasion.
- B
- Incorrect because the Aztecs under Moctezuma and later Cuauhtémoc did resist militarily; Tenochtitlan fell only after a prolonged siege.
- C
- Incorrect because Spanish firearms were less decisive than often assumed; the Tlaxcalans initially fought Cortés successfully before allying with him, and their warriors supplied the bulk of the force that besieged Tenochtitlan.
"The French colonial system in Canada differed fundamentally from English colonialism. French colonists numbered in the tens of thousands by 1700, while English colonists numbered in the hundreds of thousands. The French forged extensive alliances with indigenous peoples through the fur trade, intermarriage, and Jesuit missionary activity, creating a colonial system far more integrated with Native society than the English approach."
— Modern historian comparing French and English colonial models
The differences described between French and English colonial systems most directly contributed to which development during the colonial wars of the eighteenth century?
- AThe assimilation of indigenous peoples into French colonial society, creating a unified Franco-Native culture that English colonists were unable to compete with culturally or diplomatically
- BA permanent French demographic advantage over English colonists, as the fur trade system attracted far more French immigrants than English economic opportunities attracted English settlers
- CFrance's eventual victory in the French and Indian War, as its superior alliance with indigenous peoples overcame England's larger settler population
- DFrench military advantages in the early phases of the French and Indian War, as indigenous alliances provided crucial military intelligence, warriors, and knowledge of frontier warfareCorrect
Why D is right
French colonial alliances with indigenous peoples proved crucial in the early phases of the French and Indian War (1754-1763). Indigenous warriors allied with France provided military advantages including knowledge of forest warfare, scouting capabilities, and numerical reinforcement that offset England's larger settler population. Early English disasters — including General Braddock's catastrophic defeat in 1755 — partly reflected English unfamiliarity with Native American frontier warfare tactics and their failure to cultivate equivalent indigenous alliances. French indigenous alliances made France a far more formidable adversary than its small settler population alone would suggest.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while French colonists did intermarry with some indigenous peoples more than the English, this did not produce 'assimilation into French society'; indigenous peoples maintained their own political and cultural identities while engaging selectively in French alliances.
- B
- Incorrect because the fur trade did not attract more French immigrants than English economic opportunities attracted English settlers; the opposite was true — the English colonies had far larger settler populations, which ultimately contributed to England's strategic advantage.
- C
- Incorrect because France ultimately lost the French and Indian War despite its indigenous alliances; England's greater industrial capacity, naval superiority, and eventually effective military leadership under William Pitt proved decisive, demonstrating the limits of indigenous alliances in compensating for larger structural disadvantages.