Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 7: 1890-1945

Income tax

Income tax appears in 5 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 7: 1890-1945. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

A federal tax on individual and corporate income, made permanently constitutional by the Sixteenth Amendment, ratified in February 1913. It is graduated: rates rise with income, so the burden falls hardest on the highest earners.

Why it matters

Before 1913 the federal government had no permanent income tax. It raised money from the protective tariff and from excise taxes on alcohol and tobacco. The tariff was the regressive one, buried in the price of goods. Everyone paid it through higher prices, and manufacturers pocketed the protection. Progressives wanted revenue drawn from where the money actually was. The Supreme Court had blocked that in Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust in 1895, striking down the 1894 income tax 5-4 as a direct tax that had to be apportioned among the states by population — a practical impossibility. The Sixteenth Amendment overrode Pollock. The Underwood Tariff of October 1913 then cut tariff rates and added a 1 percent tax on incomes above $3,000. Only about 2 percent of households owed it. World War I pushed top marginal rates past 70 percent, and the income tax became the government's revenue engine.

How the exam tests it

You get either an 1890s conservative attacking the tax as an assault on capital, or a 1913 Progressive celebrating it. For the first, the credited answer is the Gilded Age defense of property rights and laissez-faire against redistribution. For the second, it is the deliberate shift of the tax burden from consumers paying the tariff to the wealthy paying graduated rates.

Don’t confuse it with

Do not mix up the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Amendments — both were ratified in 1913, but the Seventeenth created direct popular election of senators. And note that Pollock did not say income taxes were inherently illegitimate; it said this one was an unapportioned direct tax, a technical ruling the amendment simply erased.

Income tax in real questions

Example 1Medium
"The present assault upon capital is but the beginning. It will be but a stepping-stone to others, larger and more sweeping, till our political contests will become a war of the poor against the rich; a war constantly growing in intensity and bitterness. If the court sanctions the power of vexatious and unequal taxation, it will mark the hour when the sure decrement of our government will commence." -- Joseph Choate, attorney arguing against the federal income tax, Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 1895 Choate's argument most directly reflects which of the following perspectives common during the Gilded Age?
  1. AProgressive reformers' insistence that an activist government should regulate trusts and monopolies to protect ordinary consumers
  2. BPopulist farmers' demands for an inflationary monetary policy, such as free silver, to ease their crushing debt burdens
  3. CSocial Gospel advocates' conviction that Christian ethics obligated reformers to confront urban poverty
  4. DConservative elites' defense of private property rights and laissez-faire economics against government efforts to redistribute wealthCorrect

Why D is right

Choate frames the income tax as an assault on capital and a step toward class warfare. This reflects Gilded Age conservative elites who opposed government redistribution of wealth and defended private property rights, consistent with laissez-faire ideology.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because Choate argues against government intervention, the opposite of the Progressive reformers' call for an activist regulatory state.
B
Incorrect because Populist farmers wanted government action to help debtors, while Choate speaks for the wealthy opponents of such intervention.
C
Incorrect because Social Gospel advocates urged action to address inequality and urban poverty, which Choate's defense of capital opposes.
Example 2Medium
In 1913, a Progressive-era senator argued that the Sixteenth Amendment removed a barrier the Supreme Court had erected between Congress and the accumulated wealth of the Gilded Age. He observed that for twenty years income taxes had been unconstitutional, leaving the tariff as the only major source of federal revenue — a tariff that fell heaviest on those least able to bear it. Now, he argued, income could be taxed where it was greatest, shifting the burden of government to those best able to carry it. The sentiments expressed in this passage most directly reflect which of the following?
  1. AThe senator's statement reflects the mainstream Republican Party position in 1913, which had abandoned the protective tariff and now enthusiastically embraced the graduated income tax as the new financial foundation of the party of business and manufacturing
  2. BThe Sixteenth Amendment was primarily motivated by the federal government's urgent need for revenue to fund new Progressive Era social-welfare programs, and the senator's redistributive framing was added only after ratification as a convenient political justification
  3. CThe Supreme Court ruling that the senator references had declared all forms of federal taxation unconstitutional, so a constitutional amendment was required before the federal government could lawfully raise any revenue at all from any source
  4. DProgressive reformers saw the income tax as a way to shift the tax burden from consumers, who bore the protective tariff through higher prices, to wealthy individuals and corporations paying graduated ratesCorrect

Why D is right

The senator's framing captures the Progressive argument for the income tax: the protective tariff (which had been the primary federal revenue source since the Civil War) was a regressive tax that raised prices for all consumers while benefiting manufacturers. A graduated income tax would shift the burden to those with the highest incomes. The Supreme Court had struck down an 1894 income tax in Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust (1895), ruling it a direct tax requiring apportionment by state population. The Sixteenth Amendment (1913) overturned Pollock and enabled the progressive income tax.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the Republican Party was generally the party of the protective tariff, which benefited its manufacturer constituents; most Republicans remained hostile to the income tax as a threat to business and wealthy supporters, and Progressives like La Follette were a minority faction. The amendment was carried mainly by Democrats and Progressive Republicans against mainstream GOP resistance, not by an enthusiastic party consensus.
B
Incorrect because the redistributive rationale was central to the income tax's Progressive advocacy from the start, not added after ratification; Populist Party platforms in the 1890s had already demanded an income tax specifically to shift the tax burden from consumers to the wealthy, so La Follette's framing accurately represents the original reformist motivation rather than a later justification.
C
Incorrect because the Supreme Court ruling (Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust, 1895) declared income taxes on income from property to be unconstitutional direct taxes requiring apportionment — not all forms of taxation. The federal government still collected tariff revenue and other taxes, so the ruling was specific to income taxes and did not strip Congress of all revenue power.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 7: 1890-1945.