Read the following excerpt and answer the question.
"The new immigration from southern and eastern Europe is qualitatively different from the old immigration from northern and western Europe. The new immigrants — Italians, Poles, Russians, Jews, Greeks — come from non-Protestant, non-democratic societies. They have no tradition of self-government. They congregate in ethnic enclaves rather than assimilating. They are racially inferior to the Anglo-Saxon stock that built American democracy. Immigration restriction is not bigotry — it is self-preservation."
— Immigration Restriction League pamphlet, 1896
The sentiments expressed most directly contributed to which of the following?
- AThe immediate passage in the 1890s of Chinese Exclusion Act-style laws that categorically barred southern and eastern European arrivals, ending mass immigration from those regions a generation early
- BA firm bipartisan congressional consensus in favor of immigration restriction that was repeatedly blocked only by business interests demanding cheap immigrant labor for continued industrial expansion
- CThe nativist, pseudo-scientific racial arguments that culminated in the Immigration Acts of 1921 and 1924, whose national-origin quotas were designed to favor northern and western EuropeansCorrect
- DThe rise of Social Darwinism as the dominant intellectual framework for explaining social problems, displacing older religious explanations in favor of a sweeping new science of racial hierarchy
Why C is right
The IRL's racial arguments — 'inferior stock,' threat to Anglo-Saxon democracy — became the intellectual foundation for the national-origins quota system of the 1920s. Madison Grant's The Passing of the Great Race (1916) and similar nativist texts drew on this tradition, ultimately producing the Johnson-Reed Act (1924) that essentially banned immigration from southern and eastern Europe.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Chinese Exclusion-style restrictions on European immigrants were not passed in the 1890s; immigration from southern and eastern Europe in fact continued massively through the early twentieth century.
- B
- Although business interests did oppose restriction and relied on immigrant labor, there was never a settled 'bipartisan consensus' for restriction that business alone blocked; opposition was varied and immigration remained high.
- D
- While Social Darwinism and nativism overlapped, the IRL's specific contribution was to restriction legislation, not to establishing Social Darwinism as an intellectual framework, which had many applications beyond immigration.