The 1892 lockout and armed battle at Carnegie Steel's Homestead, Pennsylvania mill. Henry Clay Frick cut the tonnage rate, locked out the Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers, and on July 6 landed roughly three hundred armed Pinkerton detectives by barge. Men died on both sides in the day-long gunfight.
Why it matters
It shows exactly where public power sat. Governor Robert Pattison sent about 8,500 state militiamen, the mill reopened without a union, strike leaders were blacklisted and prosecuted, and organized labor was effectively dead in American steel until the 1930s.
How the exam tests it
A labor paper's account of Pinkertons, deaths, militia, and blacklists is followed by 'which of the following most directly challenged this viewpoint?' The answer is Carnegie's Gospel of Wealth claim that rich industrialists are trustworthy stewards who will improve workers' lives voluntarily through philanthropy. Carnegie was in Scotland while Frick broke the union, and the exam wants you to see that gap.
Don’t confuse it with
Homestead is not Pullman. Homestead in 1892 involved a private army and state militia in a single company town; Pullman in 1894 brought federal troops and a federal court injunction against Eugene Debs, which the Supreme Court upheld in In re Debs (1895).