Read the following excerpt and answer the question.
"The decision to use the atomic bomb against Japan has been made. Secretary Stimson has argued that an invasion of the Japanese home islands would cost at minimum 250,000 American casualties, and possibly far more. The bomb offers the prospect of ending the war quickly, saving American lives, and avoiding the invasion. Critics who argue we should demonstrate the bomb on an uninhabited island ignore the military reality: Japan has shown no sign of surrender, and any demonstration that failed to compel surrender would simply mean proceeding with the invasion anyway."
— White House planning document, July 1945
The justification presented most directly reflects which argument in the ongoing debate over the decision to use atomic bombs?
- AA strategic argument that demonstrating the bomb's power to Soviet observers was the decisive motive, with the projected casualty estimates serving only as a secondary public justification
- BAn appeal to just war theory's principle of proportionality, holding that destroying two cities was proportionate to the goal of ending a war that had already killed millions
- CA legal argument that the atomic bombings were permissible under international law because Japan had never signed the Hague Conventions restricting methods of warfare
- DThe casualty-based argument that using atomic bombs, despite the massive civilian deaths, was justified by the even greater American and Japanese losses that an invasion of Japan would have causedCorrect
Why D is right
The document presents the classic casualty-comparison justification: atomic bombing casualties (estimated ~150,000) versus invasion casualties (Stimson's 250,000+ American estimate, plus millions of Japanese). This remains the primary argument for the decision and is the most debated element of Hiroshima/Nagasaki historiography.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While atomic diplomacy toward the Soviets was one motive (Alperovitz's revisionist argument), this planning document specifically presents the casualty/invasion justification — the primary stated reason at the time.
- B
- While just war proportionality is a relevant ethical framework, the planning document does not use just war theory language; it relies on casualty-calculation language instead.
- C
- International-law arguments about Hague Convention applicability were not the justification presented in this document; the casualty comparison was the central public and private argument.