"The Great Compromise, Constitutional Convention, July 1787: States with large populations insisted that representation in Congress be proportional to population, while small states insisted on equal representation regardless of population. The compromise created a bicameral legislature: a House of Representatives based on population and a Senate with two senators per state."
— Modern description of the Connecticut Compromise
The Great Compromise most directly resolved which conflict at the Constitutional Convention?
- AThe fundamental disagreement between large and small states over whether seats in the new national legislature should reflect population or be equal for each stateCorrect
- BThe conflict between those who wanted a single strong executive and those who preferred executive authority vested in a committee of representatives
- CThe dispute between Southern and Northern states over whether enslaved people should be counted for representation and taxation purposes
- DThe debate between those who favored direct popular election of the president and those who preferred selection of the president by Congress
Why A is right
The Great Compromise (Connecticut Compromise), proposed by Roger Sherman, resolved the fundamental impasse between large states (supporting the Virginia Plan's proportional representation) and small states (supporting the New Jersey Plan's equal state representation). By creating a bicameral legislature with a population-based House and an equal-state-representation Senate, the compromise satisfied both large states (who would dominate the House) and small states (who had equal power in the Senate). Without this compromise, the Convention might have collapsed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the question of executive authority was addressed separately by the Convention's Committee on Detail and other deliberations; the Great Compromise specifically addressed the legislative branch's structure, not executive power.
- C
- Incorrect because the dispute over counting enslaved people was resolved by the separate Three-Fifths Compromise, not the Great Compromise; these were distinct negotiations at the Convention addressing different structural questions.
- D
- Incorrect because the method of presidential selection was resolved by the creation of the Electoral College in a separate set of deliberations; the Great Compromise concerned representation in Congress, not the selection of the executive.