The First Amendment guarantee that government may not abridge publishing. In the 1790s the contested question was its reach. Did it bar only censorship before publication, as Blackstone held, or punishment afterward as well?
Why it matters
The Sedition Act of 1798 made false, scandalous, and malicious criticism of Congress or the president a crime. It pointedly left out the vice president, Jefferson. About ten Republicans were convicted before the act expired on March 3, 1801, most of them printers and editors, but also Congressman Matthew Lyon and a handful of private critics.
How the exam tests it
Stems quote 1799 pamphleteers such as George Hay. Hay argued that a free man has the right to speak as he thinks, and he called the Sedition Act a subversion of that right. You are asked which development the passage reflects. Answer Republican opposition to the Alien and Sedition Acts on free speech and press grounds. Know the sequence too. Within months of the Acts' passage, and before most prosecutions had even been tried, Jefferson and Madison moved the fight to the states. Kentucky adopted Jefferson's Resolutions on November 16, 1798, and Virginia adopted Madison's on December 24, 1798. The act nominally allowed truth as a defense. Federalist judges and juries convicted anyway, mostly in 1799 and 1800, which is what shows the defense was worthless in their courtrooms.
Don’t confuse it with
The Zenger trial of 1735 is often treated as settling free press. It was a colonial jury's acquittal, not a constitutional rule, and truth as a defense did not stop Sedition Act convictions.