"The Prohibition Era, 1920-1933: The Eighteenth Amendment prohibited the manufacture, sale, and transportation of intoxicating liquors. Bootleggers like Al Capone built criminal enterprises worth hundreds of millions of dollars supplying illegal alcohol. Speakeasies proliferated in every American city. Federal agents like Eliot Ness tried to enforce Prohibition with limited success against organized crime's resources."
— Modern description of Prohibition
Prohibition's failure most directly demonstrated which principle about the relationship between law and social behavior?
- AThat federal enforcement of social policy is always less effective than state enforcement, since federal agents lack the local knowledge and community trust needed to suppress prohibited behaviors
- BThat constitutional amendments are inherently more difficult to enforce than ordinary legislation, since they require broader popular support to be effective
- CThat Prohibition would have succeeded if the federal government had invested adequate enforcement resources, but political opposition prevented the necessary funding for effective prohibition enforcement
- DThat laws which criminalize widely practiced behaviors can create larger criminal enterprises than the behaviors themselves while failing to eliminate the prohibited activityCorrect
Why D is right
Prohibition illustrates a fundamental criminological principle: when widely practiced behaviors are criminalized, the result is often the creation of criminal enterprises that are more dangerous than the behavior itself, while failing to eliminate the demand that drives the prohibited activity. Americans continued to drink during Prohibition, but now they did so through criminal suppliers who built enormous, violent organized crime networks. Al Capone's Chicago Outfit, Dutch Schultz's New York operation, and similar organizations grew rich and powerful supplying a demand that Prohibition had made illegal but not eliminated. The repeal of Prohibition in 1933 (Twenty-First Amendment) acknowledged this failure.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because many state governments had enacted their own Prohibition laws before the Eighteenth Amendment; the problem was not a federal-versus-state enforcement capacity issue but the fundamental challenge of suppressing behavior that millions of people engaged in voluntarily.
- B
- Incorrect because Prohibition's enforcement difficulties were not specifically related to constitutional versus statutory form; the problem was the mismatch between widely practiced behavior and legal prohibition, not the legal form in which the prohibition was expressed.
- C
- Incorrect because increased enforcement resources (which were indeed limited) would not have resolved the fundamental problem of widespread demand for a prohibited product; the failure was structural rather than merely a resource shortfall.