"The flapper is a new kind of woman. She bobs her hair, shortens her skirt, dances the Charleston, drives an automobile, and goes on dates unchaperoned. She is not ashamed of her body or her desires. She has rejected the Victorian ideal of womanhood. She is a symptom of a new age." — a magazine commentator describing the new "flapper" style, mid-1920s
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AThe flapper phenomenon marked the complete achievement of women's social equality, since women now enjoyed exactly the same freedom from social constraints as men across every area of American public and private life
- BThe 1920s challenged Victorian gender norms and sexual mores, especially for young urban women, reflecting shifting attitudes toward gender roles, personal freedom, and consumer cultureCorrect
- CThe flapper was a direct political consequence of the Nineteenth Amendment, since women who had just won the vote in 1920 immediately leveraged that right to overturn every remaining social restriction on female behavior
- DThe 'new woman' of the 1920s was primarily a rural phenomenon, since farm women, freed from the social oversight of crowded cities, adopted noticeably more liberated lifestyles than their more closely watched urban counterparts
Why B is right
The flapper represents a genuine cultural shift in gender norms during the 1920s, driven by urbanization, mass consumer culture, the automobile, mass media (movies, radio), and the after-effects of WWI's disruption of traditional social arrangements. Young women's greater public visibility — working in offices and department stores, patronizing commercial entertainment — created new spaces for social mixing and the renegotiation of gender norms. This shift was real but incomplete: flapper freedoms existed alongside persistent workplace discrimination and continued expectations of eventual domesticity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the flapper's social freedoms coexisted with persistent gender inequality in the workplace, law, and politics; women still faced discrimination in employment and the professions, and cultural liberation did not amount to economic or political equality.
- C
- Incorrect because the flapper's behavior was only loosely connected to suffrage; women had begun challenging Victorian social norms before 1920, and the cultural changes reflected urbanization, consumer culture, and generational change far more than the specific political achievement of the vote.
- D
- Incorrect because the flapper was predominantly an urban phenomenon; rural women continued to face more conservative social surveillance and had less access to the commercial entertainment venues, automobiles, and peer groups that enabled the flapper lifestyle.