The following passage describes events surrounding Reconstruction-era civil rights legislation.
The Civil Rights Act of 1875 — which prohibited racial discrimination in public accommodations including inns, theaters, and public transportation — represented the last major Reconstruction civil rights legislation. In 1883, the Supreme Court struck it down in the Civil Rights Cases, ruling that the Fourteenth Amendment prohibited only state action (discrimination by states), not private action (discrimination by private individuals and businesses).
Which of the following most directly led to the situation described in this passage?
- AThe Radical Republican Congress immediately overturned the ruling, re-enacting public accommodations protections under a different constitutional authority and restoring the federal remedies the Court had stripped away
- BEvery state court promptly adopted the Court's 'state action' doctrine as well, barring any state-level civil rights protection against private discrimination for nearly a century afterward
- CThe Court's 'state action doctrine' gutted the Fourteenth Amendment's civil rights reach, leaving private discrimination without a federal remedy until Congress found a different constitutional theoryCorrect
- DThe case proved the Fourteenth Amendment had been written specifically to reach private discrimination, an original intent the Court correctly recognized and enforced in striking down the 1875 Act
Why C is right
The Civil Rights Cases (1883) established the 'state action doctrine' — that the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause only prohibits discriminatory state action, not private discrimination. This ruling effectively eliminated the federal government's ability to prohibit private racial discrimination in public accommodations, a gap that would not be filled until the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (using Congress's commerce clause authority rather than the Fourteenth Amendment). The ruling was a major blow to Reconstruction's civil rights legacy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because by 1883 Reconstruction had ended and no Radical Republican Congress remained; the more conservative bodies that replaced it showed no interest in reinstituting civil rights legislation after the Court's ruling.
- B
- Incorrect because the 'state action doctrine' governed only federal constitutional law; state courts could still apply state civil rights laws to private discrimination, and some Northern states kept public accommodations laws covering private businesses.
- D
- Incorrect because the Fourteenth Amendment's legislative history indicates Congress meant it to reach a broader range of discriminatory conduct; the 'state action only' reading was a narrow interpretation contested by the dissenting Justice Harlan.