"The Standard Oil Company has done everything with the Pennsylvania Legislature except refine it. They have obtained secret railroad rebates, driving competitors out of business through underselling, then absorbing them into the trust. Mr. Rockefeller has, by methods which I am compelled to characterize as criminal, built the greatest, wisest, most feared business organization in the world."
— Ida Tarbell, 'History of the Standard Oil Company,' 1904
The sentiments expressed in this passage most directly reflect which of the following?
- ABroad support among railroad companies for government regulation of the secret rebates and discriminatory freight rates that fueled the growth of trusts like Standard Oil
- BThe federal government's successful prosecution and court-ordered dissolution of the Standard Oil trust under the Sherman Antitrust Act during the 1890s
- CPublic concern about the concentration of economic power in large corporations operating with little government oversight in the Gilded AgeCorrect
- DThe belief among most American business leaders that Rockefeller's methods were unethical and harmful to the national economy
Why C is right
Ida Tarbell's investigative journalism exposed Standard Oil's monopolistic practices — secret railroad rebates, predatory pricing, and corporate espionage — that allowed Rockefeller to control 90% of American oil refining by the 1880s. Her work exemplified Progressive Era muckraking and reflected widespread public anxiety about trusts and corporations that had accumulated enormous power while evading meaningful government regulation. Her series directly contributed to public pressure for antitrust enforcement.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because railroad companies were complicit in Standard Oil's secret rebate system, granting Rockefeller favorable freight rates in exchange for guaranteed volume; they profited from these arrangements and did not support regulating them away.
- B
- Incorrect because no successful federal prosecution occurred in the 1890s; Tarbell's articles appeared in 1902-1904, and the Supreme Court's antitrust dissolution of Standard Oil came in 1911, years after this passage was written.
- D
- Incorrect because most American business leaders in the Gilded Age admired Rockefeller's methods as models of efficient organization; the criticism came from reformers, muckrakers, and small competitors, not the broader business community.
In an 1900 campaign speech, Theodore Roosevelt argued that trusts had to be controlled, but that not all large accumulations of wealth were the problem. He drew a line between businessmen who had built their fortunes through their own fair efforts and deserved to keep them, and those who had built fortunes by corrupting judges, bribing legislators, and destroying competition — the latter, he said, would be pursued "to the last dollar."
Which of the following best explains why the author expressed this viewpoint?
- ARoosevelt's campaign reflected the Democratic Party's long-standing commitment to dismantling every large corporation regardless of how it had been formed or whether it competed fairly in the marketplace
- BRoosevelt was responding to a recent Supreme Court decision that had struck down all federal antitrust regulation as an unconstitutional interference with private property and freedom of contract
- CRoosevelt's argument was intended to build support for the Socialist Party's platform of nationalizing all industrial corporations as the only effective response to concentrated trust power
- DRoosevelt's position reflected the Progressive Era's effort to distinguish 'good' from 'bad' trusts, regulating corrupt monopoly power while accepting legitimate large-scale enterpriseCorrect
Why D is right
Roosevelt's distinction between acceptable and unacceptable business concentration reflects his regulatory — rather than structural — approach to the trust problem. As president, Roosevelt became famous as a 'trust buster,' but he actually preferred regulation of large corporations over breaking them up entirely. He distinguished between 'good trusts' (large but fair) and 'bad trusts' (monopolistic through corruption and coercion). This approach, reflected in his 1900 campaign rhetoric, shaped his later use of the Sherman Act and the Bureau of Corporations to regulate, not destroy, big business.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this describes a more radical position than Roosevelt's; he explicitly limits his concern to corrupt methods ('bribing legislators'), not all large corporations; the 'break them all up' approach was associated with Brandeis Democrats, not Roosevelt.
- B
- Incorrect because no such Supreme Court ruling had occurred by 1900; the E.C. Knight ruling (1895) had limited but not eliminated antitrust law; Roosevelt's argument is proactive, not responsive to a court decision stripping all regulatory authority.
- C
- Incorrect because Roosevelt explicitly defended legitimate wealth accumulation (fortunes built 'through their own fair efforts'), which is incompatible with socialist nationalization; he was a Progressive reformer, not a socialist.
Read the following excerpt and answer the question.
"Standard Oil controls 90 percent of American oil refining. It has achieved this dominance not through superior products or service but through railroad rebates, predatory pricing, and the systematic destruction of competition. It charges high prices in markets where it has no competition and low prices — below cost — in markets where competitors remain. When the competitor is destroyed, the prices rise. This is not commerce; it is organized extortion."
— investigative journalist Ida Tarbell, History of the Standard Oil Company, 1904
Tarbell's exposé most directly contributed to which of the following?
- ACongressional passage of the Sherman Antitrust Act in 1890, the federal law written specifically to break up the Standard Oil Trust and the abuses Tarbell would later document
- BA nationwide consumer boycott of Standard Oil products that sharply reduced the company's market share and showed that public pressure could rival legal action against monopoly
- CPresident Cleveland's decision to prosecute Standard Oil under the Sherman Act, entering Tarbell's reporting as documentary evidence in the federal antitrust case against the trust
- DThe Supreme Court's 1911 ruling in Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States, which ordered the trust dissolved as an illegal combination in restraint of trade under the Sherman Antitrust ActCorrect
Why D is right
Tarbell's 1904 muckraking series created public pressure that contributed to Theodore Roosevelt's antitrust prosecutions of Standard Oil. The Supreme Court's 1911 dissolution order was the culmination: Standard Oil was broken into 34 separate companies, though many reconsolidated over time.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Sherman Antitrust Act was passed in 1890, fourteen years before Tarbell's exposé; it could not have been inspired by reporting that did not yet exist.
- B
- While Tarbell's work did galvanize public opinion, the primary historical consequence was the federal antitrust prosecution and 1911 dissolution order, not a consumer boycott.
- C
- It was Theodore Roosevelt (1901-1909), not Grover Cleveland, whose administration prosecuted Standard Oil, and that prosecution built toward the 1911 decision rather than predating it.