Historians note that after the collapse of the American Railway Union's Pullman Strike, Eugene Debs came to argue that the labor movement could not rely on trade unionism alone. In his view, organizing workers into craft unions while standing aside from politics was not enough: railroad barons and mine owners sat in the U.S. Senate, wrote the tariff laws, and controlled the state legislatures that broke strikes with injunctions. Debs concluded that if workers wanted shorter hours and safer conditions, they needed to elect lawmakers who would legislate for labor rather than against it, pushing the movement beyond pure collective bargaining and into political action.
The historical significance of Debs's argument relates most directly to which of the following?
- AThe rise and fall of the Knights of Labor, whose collapse after the Haymarket affair supposedly proved that labor could succeed only by restricting membership to skilled workers in particular crafts
- BThe AFL's success in lobbying Congress to pass the Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914, which exempted unions from antitrust prosecution and gave organized labor new legal protection from injunctions
- CSamuel Gompers's founding of the American Federation of Labor in 1886, which committed the mainstream labor movement to collective bargaining over wages and hours rather than broad social reform
- DThe tension between the AFL's 'pure and simple' craft unionism, which avoided independent political action, and advocates of labor parties, a path Debs later took through the Socialist PartyCorrect
Why D is right
Debs's argument represents a fundamental strategic debate: Gompers's AFL pursued 'pure and simple' trade unionism (wages, hours, conditions through collective bargaining, avoiding third-party politics). Debs, radicalized by the Pullman Strike defeat, moved toward socialist political action. This debate — labor as economic vs. political movement — defined American labor history.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Knights of Labor declined for many reasons, including the Haymarket bombing's association with radicalism and the order's inability to discipline strikes; the craft-only argument was the AFL's own position that Debs was challenging, not the lesson he draws here.
- B
- The Clayton Act came in 1914, nearly two decades after this 1895 speech, and it represented the kind of eventual political engagement Debs urged, not a refutation of his point about the necessity of political action.
- C
- Gompers founded the AFL in 1886, before this speech, and the AFL's 'pure and simple' unionism is precisely what Debs argues against rather than what his speech describes or endorses.