The following is a practice passage.
Upon signing a defense appropriations bill, a president issued a written statement. The statement praised the bill's funding for military readiness but singled out a section requiring the executive branch to notify two congressional committees before transferring detainees. The president declared that this section would be interpreted consistently with the president's constitutional authority as commander in chief and that the executive branch would treat it as advisory rather than binding. Several members of Congress responded that the president had accepted the money in the bill while discarding the conditions Congress attached to it.
Which of the following best explains why the members of Congress described in the passage objected to the president's action?
- AIt was a pocket veto, because the president kept the bill unsigned while Congress was adjourned and unable to respond
- BIt inserted new statutory language into the bill that Congress had never debated, voted on, or approved
- CIt violated the War Powers Resolution by deploying troops abroad without congressional authorization
- DIt let the president disregard part of a signed law, nullifying a provision without a veto Congress could overrideCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes a signing statement. The president signed the bill, then declared that the detainee-notification section would be treated as advisory rather than binding. The critics' complaint, that the president 'accepted the money' while 'discarding the conditions,' is the central objection to signing statements: they work as a de facto line-item veto. The president keeps the parts of a law he likes and declines to enforce a provision he objects to. A normal veto would reject the whole bill and give Congress the chance to override it, and this approach skips that check.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- A pocket veto happens only when a president does not sign a bill and Congress has adjourned. The passage says the president signed the bill, so no pocket veto took place.
- B
- The president did not change the bill's text. The statement announced how the executive would interpret and enforce an existing section, and signing statements cannot add statutory language.
- C
- The disputed section concerned notifying Congress before detainee transfers, not deploying troops. Nothing in the passage involves committing forces abroad or the War Powers Resolution.