The table shows hypothetical data on how often Congress supported the President's stated position on roll-call votes during five presidential administrations.
| Administration | Foreign policy votes: support for President (%) | Domestic policy votes: support for President (%) |
|---|---|---|
| President A | 78 | 61 |
| President B | 72 | 55 |
| President C | 81 | 58 |
| President D | 69 | 52 |
| President E | 75 | 49 |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table and gives a plausible explanation for the pattern?
- AEach president won more support on foreign policy votes, consistent with congressional deference to the executive abroadCorrect
- BEach president won more support on domestic policy votes, consistent with the Constitution giving the President explicit control over domestic lawmaking
- CSupport on foreign policy votes fell steadily from President A to President E, suggesting that Congress has steadily reclaimed its foreign policy powers
- DThe gap between foreign and domestic support was identical for all five presidents, suggesting that Congress treats the two policy areas in the same way
Why A is right
In every row of the table, the President's foreign policy support (69-81%) is higher than his domestic support (49-61%), so the gap is 17-26 points for every administration. This fits the idea that presidents have more discretion in foreign policy. Congress tends to defer to the executive abroad because the President has better access to intelligence, the Constitution's foreign affairs provisions are less detailed, there is long historical precedent for executive leadership, and diplomacy and crises call for speed and a unified voice. The Supreme Court recognized broad presidential foreign affairs power in United States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp. (1936).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Misreads the table: every president's domestic support (49-61%) is lower than his foreign support (69-81%). The Constitution also gives the President no explicit control over domestic lawmaking, since Congress holds the legislative power.
- C
- Misreads the trend: foreign policy support does not fall steadily (78, 72, 81, 69, 75). It rises from President B to President C and again from President D to President E, so the data show no steady congressional reclaiming of power.
- D
- Misreads the table: the gaps are 17, 17, 23, 17 and 26 points, so they are not identical. The consistent gap actually shows that Congress treats the two areas differently.
The following is a practice passage.
Upon signing a defense appropriations bill, a president issued a written statement. The statement praised the bill's funding for military readiness but singled out a section requiring the executive branch to notify two congressional committees before transferring detainees. The president declared that this section would be interpreted consistently with the president's constitutional authority as commander in chief and that the executive branch would treat it as advisory rather than binding. Several members of Congress responded that the president had accepted the money in the bill while discarding the conditions Congress attached to it.
Which of the following best explains why the members of Congress described in the passage objected to the president's action?
- AIt was a pocket veto, because the president kept the bill unsigned while Congress was adjourned and unable to respond
- BIt inserted new statutory language into the bill that Congress had never debated, voted on, or approved
- CIt violated the War Powers Resolution by deploying troops abroad without congressional authorization
- DIt let the president disregard part of a signed law, nullifying a provision without a veto Congress could overrideCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes a signing statement. The president signed the bill, then declared that the detainee-notification section would be treated as advisory rather than binding. The critics' complaint, that the president 'accepted the money' while 'discarding the conditions,' is the central objection to signing statements: they work as a de facto line-item veto. The president keeps the parts of a law he likes and declines to enforce a provision he objects to. A normal veto would reject the whole bill and give Congress the chance to override it, and this approach skips that check.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- A pocket veto happens only when a president does not sign a bill and Congress has adjourned. The passage says the president signed the bill, so no pocket veto took place.
- B
- The president did not change the bill's text. The statement announced how the executive would interpret and enforce an existing section, and signing statements cannot add statutory language.
- C
- The disputed section concerned notifying Congress before detainee transfers, not deploying troops. Nothing in the passage involves committing forces abroad or the War Powers Resolution.
The table shows hypothetical data on federal immigration removals (deportations) in the year before and the year after a president issued a directive setting enforcement priorities under the Article II duty to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." The underlying immigration statutes did not change between the two years.
| Category of individual | Removals, year before directive | Removals, year after directive |
|---|---|---|
| Convicted of serious crimes | 82,000 | 91,000 |
| Recent border crossers | 110,000 | 118,000 |
| Arrived as children, no criminal record | 14,000 | 1,200 |
| Long-term residents, no criminal record | 36,000 | 36,500 |
Which of the following conclusions about the president's use of executive power is best supported by the data?
- AThe president halted enforcement of immigration law as a whole, since total removals fell sharply
- BRemovals declined in every category, reflecting a general cut in federal enforcement resources
- CEnforcement was sharply deprioritized for one category while removals in others held steady or roseCorrect
- DThe president pardoned people who arrived as children, erasing their pending removal cases altogether and permanently
Why C is right
The table shows removals of people who arrived as children with no criminal record falling from 14,000 to 1,200, a drop of more than 90 percent. Over the same period, removals rose in every other category: convicted criminals (82,000 to 91,000), recent border crossers (110,000 to 118,000), and long-term residents with no criminal record (36,000 to 36,500). Total removals stayed nearly flat (242,000 to 246,700). Because the statutes did not change, this pattern points to prosecutorial discretion: the president chose which violations to prioritize instead of stopping enforcement altogether. Presidents justify enforcement priorities like this under the Take Care Clause, and DACA is the real-world example. Critics argue that categorical non-enforcement goes beyond discretion and amounts to failing to faithfully execute the law.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Total removals actually rose slightly (242,000 to 246,700), and three categories increased, so the data do not show a general halt to enforcement. This confuses selective non-enforcement with abandoning the law.
- B
- Misreads the table: removals rose in three of the four categories, so the decline was not across the board and does not point to an overall resource cut.
- D
- The pardon power applies to federal crimes, not to civil removal proceedings, and the data still show 1,200 removals in that category. The pattern reflects enforcement priorities (prosecutorial discretion), not pardons.