Read the following practice passage.
A president announces a plan to build a network of new federal research centers and directs an executive agency to begin construction. Leaders in the House and Senate object to the project. Rather than passing a law that forbids it outright, they add a provision to the agency's annual funding bill stating that none of the money the bill provides may be used for the centers. The president signs the bill to keep the agency operating. Months later, the agency halts all planning because, its director explains, it has no lawful source of money for the work.
The congressional action described in the passage is grounded most directly in which constitutional provision?
- AThe Commerce Clause, because the research centers would affect economic activity across state lines
- BThe Necessary and Proper Clause, because Congress may pass any law needed to carry out its enumerated powers
- CThe Take Care Clause, because the agency director concluded that the president could not faithfully execute a program Congress had not approved
- DThe Appropriations Clause, because executive agencies may spend Treasury money only as Congress has authorized by lawCorrect
Why D is right
In the passage, Congress does not ban the research centers outright; it writes a limitation into the agency's funding bill so that none of the appropriated money can go to them. The agency stops because, as its director says, it has no lawful source of money. That is the power of the purse. Article I, Section 9, Clause 7 (the Appropriations Clause) bars any money from being drawn from the Treasury except under appropriations made by law, so Congress can check executive initiatives by refusing to fund them.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Commerce Clause lets Congress regulate interstate commerce. The passage describes Congress cutting off funding, not regulating economic activity, so the commerce effects of the centers have nothing to do with the check.
- B
- The Necessary and Proper Clause expands the means Congress may use to carry out its enumerated powers, but it is not the source of the spending restriction that stopped the agency.
- C
- The Take Care Clause is a duty placed on the president, not a congressional power. The agency stopped because it had no appropriated funds, not because of anything in the president's duty to execute the laws.