The table shows hypothetical data from a panel survey that asked the same voters to describe their party identification, recorded how they voted for the U.S. House, and asked them again four years later.
| Party identification | Share of electorate | Voted for own party's House candidate | Same identification four years later |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strong Democrat | 20% | 94% | 91% |
| Weak Democrat | 14% | 81% | 72% |
| Independent, leans Democratic | 12% | 84% | 65% |
| Pure independent | 10% | n/a | 48% |
| Independent, leans Republican | 12% | 83% | 63% |
| Weak Republican | 13% | 79% | 70% |
| Strong Republican | 19% | 95% | 92% |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- AIndependents who leaned toward a party backed its House candidates at higher rates than that party's weak identifiers didCorrect
- BWeak identifiers with each party backed its House candidates at higher rates than independents leaning toward it did
- CRepublican identifiers at every level of strength backed their party's House candidates more often than Democratic identifiers at the same level did
- DIndependents leaning toward a party were more likely than that party's weak identifiers to report the same identification four years later
Why A is right
In the table's vote column, Democratic leaners voted for Democratic House candidates at 84% versus 81% for weak Democrats, and Republican leaners voted for Republican House candidates at 83% versus 79% for weak Republicans, so for both parties the leaners were the more loyal voters. This fits the idea that party identification is a psychological attachment rather than a formal label: many self-described independents act like partisans. The other statements misread the table: B reverses the vote comparison, C holds only for the strong-identifier rows, and D applies the vote pattern to the stability column, where leaners were actually less stable (65% and 63%) than weak identifiers (72% and 70%).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Reverses the comparison in the vote column: weak Democrats (81%) and weak Republicans (79%) backed their party's House candidates at LOWER rates than Democratic leaners (84%) and Republican leaners (83%).
- C
- Generalizes from the strong-identifier row only: strong Republicans (95%) edged strong Democrats (94%), but weak Republicans (79%) trailed weak Democrats (81%) and Republican leaners (83%) trailed Democratic leaners (84%).
- D
- Reads the wrong column: leaners were more loyal in their House vote, but in the stability column they were LESS likely than weak identifiers to keep the same identification (65% vs. 72% for Democrats, 63% vs. 70% for Republicans).
Party identification is best described as
- AA psychological attachment to a party that predisposes a citizen to vote for its candidatesCorrect
- BThe position a citizen holds on the liberal-conservative ideological spectrum, apart from party
- CThe formal party registration a state government records when a citizen registers to vote
- DMembership in a party that requires paying dues and endorsing the official party platform
Why A is right
Party identification, as defined by the Michigan model of voting behavior (Campbell, Converse, Miller, and Stokes in The American Voter, 1960), is a psychological attachment or affective orientation toward a political party that individuals develop over time and that strongly predisposes them to vote for that party's candidates. It is an attitudinal, not a formal legal, concept — people can have strong Democratic or Republican party identification without being formally registered with either party.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because ideological self-identification (liberal vs. conservative) is related to but distinct from party identification; some conservatives identify as Democrats and some liberals identify as Republicans, though the correlation has grown stronger.
- C
- Incorrect because formal party registration is a legal administrative act required in many states for primary election participation; party identification is a psychological concept that can differ from formal registration.
- D
- Incorrect because American political parties do not require paid membership; party identification is a psychological phenomenon, not a formal organizational membership with dues and obligations.