Read the following practice passage.
In 1988, voters in a rural county gave Party X's presidential nominee about 60 percent of their votes, while the same ballots re-elected the county's longtime Party Y member of the House with about 58 percent. Over the next three decades, the share of county residents registered with each party barely changed, and turnout held near 60 percent of eligible adults. In 2020, Party X's presidential nominee again won about 60 percent in the county, and this time Party X's House candidate also won, with about 59 percent, defeating a Party Y challenger who campaigned heavily on local road and farm projects.
Which of the following statements is best supported by the passage?
- ABetween 1988 and 2020, most of the county's voters switched their party registration from Party Y to Party X.
- BA surge in turnout in 2020 brought many new voters to the polls, and they decided the county's House race.
- CIn 1988 many county voters backed different parties for president and the House, a pattern that had largely disappeared there by 2020.Correct
- DBetween 1988 and 2020, the county's presidential vote shifted toward Party Y while its House vote shifted toward Party X.
Why C is right
In 1988 Party X won about 60 percent of the county's presidential vote, while Party Y's House member won about 58 percent on the same ballots. So many voters must have chosen different parties for the two offices, which is split-ticket voting. In 2020 the presidential and House results nearly matched (60 and 59 percent for Party X), even though the Party Y challenger ran on local projects. Party registration and turnout stayed steady, so the change came from the same kinds of voters choosing one party for both offices. This matches the national decline in split-ticket voting as partisan polarization has grown.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage says the share of residents registered with each party barely changed, so the shift was not caused by voters changing their registration (a realignment).
- B
- The passage says turnout held near 60 percent, so a turnout surge did not produce the change.
- D
- This misreads the passage. The presidential vote stayed about the same (about 60 percent for Party X in both years). Only the House vote moved, toward Party X.