- AThe original design required the president to be chosen by Congress if no candidate won a majority, giving Congress too much influence over executive selection
- BThe original design made no provision for a vice president, leaving the line of succession unresolved should the president die or become incapacitated
- CThe original design let each state legislature decide how its electors were chosen, producing inconsistent selection methods that the amendment sought to standardize
- DThe original design gave each elector two votes for president, with the runner-up becoming vice president, allowing a same-party tie or a divided executiveCorrect
Why D is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The contingent election in the House, used when no candidate wins an electoral-vote majority, existed in the original design and was kept by the Twelfth Amendment; the flaw the amendment fixed was the two-vote tie between same-party candidates, not congressional influence.
- B
- Article II of the original Constitution created the vice presidency, and questions of presidential succession were later addressed by the Twenty-Fifth Amendment; a missing vice presidency was not the defect the Twelfth Amendment corrected.
- C
- The Constitution left the manner of appointing electors to each state legislature, and the Twelfth Amendment neither changed nor standardized that discretion, which states still exercise today.