Read the following practice passage.
Textbooks often describe the national government as three branches, each with its own job. That picture misleads. A president who wants a new program cannot simply order it; the program needs money that only Congress can appropriate. Lawmakers who pass a bill still need a signature, or two-thirds of each chamber, to make it law. Judges who strike down an action rely on executive officials to carry out the ruling. Because each branch holds only a piece of what any major policy requires, a president's real power lies less in formal commands than in the ability to bargain with people who do not have to say yes.
Which of the following statements is most consistent with the author's argument in the passage?
- AThe framers gave each branch exclusive powers so that no branch would ordinarily need cooperation from another branch to act.
- BThe formal powers listed in Article II are the main source of a president's influence over national policy.
- CThe Tenth Amendment limits national power by reserving undelegated powers to the states.
- DA president's success in shaping policy depends largely on persuading others who share authority over outcomes.Correct
Why D is right
The passage argues that each branch holds only a piece of what policy requires: Congress controls money, the president's signature (or a two-thirds override) is needed for law, and courts rely on the executive to enforce their rulings. It concludes that a president's real power lies 'less in formal commands than in the ability to bargain with people who do not have to say yes.' Choice D restates this conclusion, which is the idea that separated institutions share powers.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This is the textbook picture of three branches 'each with its own job,' which the author says 'misleads.' The passage stresses that the branches depend on each other, not that they act alone.
- B
- The passage explicitly places a president's real power 'less in formal commands' than in bargaining, so treating formal Article II powers as the main source of influence contradicts the author.
- C
- This is an accurate statement about federalism, but the passage is about relations among the three national branches and says nothing about national-state relations.