Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Interactions Among Branches of Government

Judicial decision making

Judicial decision making appears in 3 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Interactions Among Branches of Government. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How courts reach rulings, centered on stare decisis: the practice of treating earlier decisions as controlling in similar cases. Courts can overrule precedent, but they do so rarely and must explain why.

Why it matters

Stare decisis gives the law stability and predictability, which is why a court that overturns many precedents is accused of playing politics. It also explains why Brown v. Board of Education (1954) was so dramatic: it rejected Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) after 58 years.

How the exam tests it

Expect a table of a court's decisions across several terms, listing cases decided, decisions that followed precedent, and precedents overruled. You must compute shares rather than compare raw counts, and you must not read a cause into a mere association.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse the raw number of precedent-following decisions with the share. If the docket shrinks, the count can fall while the share rises, so always divide by cases decided.

Judicial decision making in real questions

Example 1Easier
The table shows hypothetical data on the decisions of a supreme court over five consecutive terms. | Term | Cases decided | Decisions that followed an earlier ruling as controlling | Earlier rulings explicitly overruled | |---|---|---|---| | Term 1 | 80 | 68 | 1 | | Term 2 | 74 | 63 | 0 | | Term 3 | 70 | 61 | 2 | | Term 4 | 66 | 52 | 3 | | Term 5 | 62 | 47 | 4 | Which of the following statements about the court's reliance on the principle of stare decisis is supported by the data in the table?
  1. AThe number of precedents the Court overruled rose in every term shown
  2. BTerm 3 had the highest share of rulings that followed precedentCorrect
  3. CThe share of rulings that followed precedent fell in every term shown
  4. DDeciding fewer cases caused the Court to overrule more precedents

Why B is right

Stare decisis is the principle of following precedent, so the relevant measure is the column of decisions that followed an earlier ruling as controlling, taken as a share of cases decided. The shares are 68/80 = 85.0%, 63/74 = about 85.1%, 61/70 = about 87.1%, 52/66 = about 78.8%, and 47/62 = about 75.8%. Term 3 has the highest share, so B is supported. The raw count of precedent-following decisions falls every term, but the share does not (C). Overrulings dip in Term 2 (A). The table shows only an association between docket size and overrulings, not a cause (D).
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Misreads the overruled column: overrulings fell from 1 in Term 1 to 0 in Term 2 before rising, so they did not rise in every term.
C
Confuses raw counts with shares: the number of decisions following precedent fell every term (68, 63, 61, 52, 47), but the share rose from 85% to about 85.1% to about 87.1% before falling.
D
Unsupported causal leap: cases decided fell while overrulings mostly rose, but a correlation in five terms of hypothetical data does not show that the smaller docket caused the overrulings.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Interactions Among Branches of Government.