The table shows hypothetical data on impeachment votes involving five federal officials. In every vote, all 435 House members and all 100 senators voted.
| Official | House vote on articles of impeachment (yes-no) | Senate trial vote (guilty-not guilty) |
|---|---|---|
| Judge P | 230-205 | 70-30 |
| Judge Q | 210-225 | No trial held |
| Secretary R | 240-195 | 60-40 |
| President S | 300-135 | 66-34 |
| Judge T | 280-155 | 67-33 |
Based on the data in the table and the constitutional requirements for impeachment and removal, which of the following statements is accurate?
- ASecretary R was removed from office, since a clear majority of the senators voting found R guilty
- BJudge P and Judge T were removed, while President S was acquitted despite 66 guilty votesCorrect
- CPresident S was removed, since the House impeached S by more than a two-thirds margin
- DJudge Q was impeached but not removed, since the Senate never held a trial on Q
Why B is right
The Constitution lets the House impeach by a simple majority (218 of 435 here) and requires a two-thirds vote of senators present to convict and remove (67 of 100 here). Reading the table: Judge P (70 guilty) and Judge T (67 guilty) reach the two-thirds threshold and are removed. President S was impeached (300-135) but received only 66 guilty votes, one short of two-thirds, so S was acquitted. Secretary R's 60 guilty votes and Judge Q's failed House vote (210 yes, short of a majority) mean neither was removed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misapplies the Senate threshold: 60 of 100 is a majority, but conviction requires two-thirds (67 of 100), so the table shows Secretary R was acquitted.
- C
- Confuses which chamber's margin matters: the House needs only a simple majority to impeach, and removal depends on the Senate vote, where President S's 66 guilty votes fall short of two-thirds.
- D
- Misreads Judge Q's row: 210 yes votes is fewer than half of 435, so the House never impeached Q, which is why no Senate trial was held.