The following is a practice passage.
When a misguided policy is carried out by a council of several officers, each member can claim that he was outvoted or misled by the others, and the public cannot tell whom to remove at the next opportunity. Disputes among equals also slow the government precisely when events demand a quick and confidential response. Placing the power to execute the laws in one officer does not free that officer from restraint. It makes the restraint visible, because the people and their representatives always know whose conduct to examine.
Which of the following statements is most consistent with the author's argument in the passage?
- AExecutive power should be divided among several officers so that each can check the ambitions of the others.
- BThe chief safeguard against executive abuse is the power of the legislature to approve or reject appointments.
- CPlacing executive power in one officer strengthens accountability because the public can identify whom to blame for failures.Correct
- DConfidential executive decision-making should be limited because it keeps the public from judging how power is used.
Why C is right
The passage argues that a council lets each member shift blame onto the others, so 'the public cannot tell whom to remove.' It also says that putting executive power in one officer 'makes the restraint visible' because people 'always know whose conduct to examine.' That is the accountability argument in choice C, the same reasoning Hamilton gives for a unitary executive in Federalist No. 70. The passage also says a single executive allows a 'quick and confidential response,' which supports its preference for one officer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This is the case for a plural executive in which officers check one another, the Anti-Federalist view. The passage rejects it: the author says a council spreads blame around and slows action.
- B
- Senate confirmation is a real check on the executive, but the passage never mentions appointments or legislative approval. Its safeguard is public visibility of one officer's conduct.
- D
- This reverses the passage. The author treats a 'quick and confidential response' as something the government needs and counts it as an advantage of a single executive, not a danger to limit.