Read the following practice passage.
A deputy attorney general appoints an outside lawyer to investigate whether senior White House aides obstructed a federal inquiry. Under department regulations, the lawyer may be removed only for misconduct or other good cause, and any removal must be reported to Congress. Supporters argue that officials should not control investigations into their own conduct. Critics respond that prosecution is an executive function, so the president, who answers to voters, must be able to direct and dismiss anyone exercising it.
The disagreement between the supporters and the critics in the passage most directly reflects a tension between which of the following?
- AThe Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial and the Senate's sole power to try cases of impeachment
- BJudicial review of executive acts and the political question doctrine's limits on federal courts
- CThe Article II vesting of executive power in the president and independent accountability for high-level officialsCorrect
- DThe president's commander-in-chief authority and Congress's constitutional power to declare war
Why C is right
The passage's critics invoke the idea that prosecution is an executive function the president must be able to direct and remove, which rests on Article II's vesting of executive power in the president. The supporters argue that officials should not control investigations into their own conduct, which is the case for independent accountability of high-level officials. The removal-only-for-cause rule and the report to Congress are attempts to balance those two values, so the debate reflects the tension in choice C.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage involves an executive-branch prosecutor and a removal rule, not jury trials or the Senate's role in impeachment trials; neither side's argument concerns the Sixth Amendment.
- B
- Neither side in the passage argues about whether courts may hear the dispute; the conflict is over who controls the prosecutor within the executive branch, not judicial review or the political question doctrine.
- D
- The passage is about a criminal investigation of White House aides, not military action; the war powers conflict between the commander in chief and Congress is a different interbranch tension.