Read the following practice passage describing a hypothetical country.
In a certain democracy, four national elections had very different effects. In the first, the governing party lost in a landslide after a corruption scandal; four years later, voters returned it to power with its old base of support intact. In the second, a popular candidate drew record turnout from first-time voters, most of whom did not vote again. In the third, the winning party prevailed narrowly, but factory workers and city voters from immigrant neighborhoods shifted to it and stayed loyal for three decades, giving it control of the legislature for most of that period. In the fourth, a new third party won a quarter of the vote but dissolved before the next election.
Which election described in the passage best fits political scientists' definition of a realigning election?
- AThe third election, which the winning party carried by only a narrow marginCorrect
- BThe first election, which the challenging party won by a landslide
- CThe second election, which drew record voter turnout
- DThe fourth election, in which a third party won a quarter of the vote
Why A is right
A realigning election is one in which large groups of voters lastingly shift their party loyalties, creating a new majority coalition that lasts for a generation (as the New Deal coalition did after 1932). The passage shows this only for the third election: factory workers and city voters from immigrant neighborhoods moved to the winning party and stayed loyal for three decades, giving it control of the legislature for most of that time. The narrow margin does not matter, because realignment is about how durable the coalition shift is, not how large the win was. The other three elections produced only temporary effects: the defeated party came back with its old base, the new voters did not vote again, and the third party dissolved.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The passage says the governing party returned to power four years later with its old support intact. A landslide caused by short-term factors like a scandal, with no lasting change in coalitions, is a deviating election, not a realignment.
- C
- The passage says most of the new voters did not vote again. A one-time rise in turnout does not create a durable new coalition, so this election did not realign the parties.
- D
- The passage says the third party dissolved before the next election. A strong but short-lived third-party showing does not permanently shift voter loyalties between the parties.