Read the following practice passage.
When a vacancy opens on a federal trial court, the White House counsel's office does not begin with a national search. Staff first ask the state's senators who belong to the president's party to recommend candidates, often drawn from a screening panel those senators appoint. If one of those senators objects to a name, the Judiciary Committee chair usually declines to schedule a hearing, and the nomination quietly lapses. Senators of the other party are kept informed but rarely shape the shortlist. For appellate seats covering several states, similar consultation occurs, but a single senator's objection carries noticeably less weight.
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the passage?
- AObjections from home-state senators carry roughly the same weight for multistate appellate seats as for trial-court seats.
- BHome-state senators of the president's party can stop a trial-court nomination before any committee hearing is held.Correct
- CHome-state senators from the opposing party usually play the leading role in assembling the shortlist of trial-court candidates.
- DA trial-court nominee opposed by a home-state senator is usually defeated by a recorded vote of the full Senate.
Why B is right
The passage states that when a home-state senator of the president's party objects, the Judiciary Committee chair usually declines to schedule a hearing and the nomination lapses. That describes senatorial courtesy: an informal norm that gives these senators an effective veto over federal trial-court (district court) nominations before any formal Senate action, which is why presidents consult them first.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage says that for multistate appellate seats a single senator's objection carries noticeably less weight, so the claim of equal weight contradicts the source.
- C
- The passage says senators of the other party are kept informed but rarely shape the shortlist; it is the president's own party's home-state senators who recommend candidates.
- D
- According to the passage, an opposed nomination lapses without a hearing. It does not reach a recorded floor vote, so the full Senate never defeats it.