The table shows hypothetical survey data from four federal agencies, before and after new limits on the partisan political activity of career civil service employees took effect. "Pressured" means the share of employees who said a supervisor had asked them to donate to or work for a political campaign.
| Agency | Pressured (before) | Pressured (after) | Voted in last election (before) | Voted in last election (after) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| W | 18% | 4% | 71% | 70% |
| X | 12% | 3% | 68% | 69% |
| Y | 22% | 6% | 74% | 72% |
| Z | 9% | 8% | 66% | 66% |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- AAgency Z had the largest decline in employees reporting supervisor pressure to donate or campaign.
- BSupervisor pressure fell in all four agencies while voting stayed nearly flat.Correct
- CAgencies with the highest pre-change voting rates saw the smallest declines in reported supervisor pressure.
- DAgency X, which ended with the lowest reported pressure, also saw the largest drop of any agency.
Why B is right
Read the table row by row. Reported pressure dropped in every agency: W went from 18% to 4%, X from 12% to 3%, Y from 22% to 6%, and Z from 9% to 8%. Voting moved by no more than 2 points in any agency: W 71 to 70, X 68 to 69, Y 74 to 72, Z 66 to 66. This pattern matches the rationale for Hatch Act-style limits on partisan activity. The limits are meant to keep supervisors from coercing employees and to stop the civil service from becoming a campaign machine. Employees keep their right to vote. Choice A uses the wrong row. Choice C reverses the relationship in the data. Choice D confuses the lowest ending level with the largest decline.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Wrong row. Agency Z fell only from 9% to 8%, a 1-point drop and the smallest in the table. Agency Y had the largest decline, falling 16 points from 22% to 6%.
- C
- This reverses the pattern. Agency Y had the highest voting rate before the change (74%) and also had the largest decline in pressure (16 points). Agency Z had the lowest voting rate (66%) and the smallest decline (1 point).
- D
- This mixes up the ending level with the size of the change. Agency X did end with the lowest pressure (3%), but it fell only 9 points. Agency W fell 14 points and Agency Y fell 16.
Read the following practice passage.
In the city described in this practice passage, the ward boss survived more than one blow. When competitive exams took over municipal hiring, he shifted his loyal workers to contractors who did business with the city. When federal relief checks began arriving, families still came to him for help dealing with the new agencies. Even as many residents left for the suburbs, his slate kept winning. What finally broke him was a change in who chose the slate. Once nominees had to win a vote of ordinary party members rather than his approval in a back room, rivals could appeal to voters directly, and his endorsement no longer decided who appeared on the ballot.
Based on the passage, which development did the most to end the ward boss's power?
- ALetting party voters choose the nomineesCorrect
- BMerit exams that replaced patronage hiring for city jobs
- CFederal relief programs that took over the aid ward captains gave
- DResidents moving from the city wards out to the suburbs
Why A is right
The passage walks through several developments that historically weakened urban machines (merit hiring, federal relief, suburban migration) and says the boss survived each one. It identifies the decisive change as 'a change in who chose the slate': nominees had to win a vote of ordinary party members instead of the boss's back-room approval. That describes the direct primary, which took control of nominations away from party bosses and gave it to voters. So A is the development the passage credits with ending his power.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Civil service reform is a real cause of machine decline in general, but the passage says the boss survived it by moving his workers to city contractors.
- C
- New Deal-era welfare programs did weaken machines nationally, but the passage says families still relied on the boss to navigate the new agencies, so relief did not end his power here.
- D
- Suburban migration did erode some machines' bases, but the passage states that his slate kept winning even as residents left.