Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010) most directly held that
- ACorporations may donate unlimited amounts directly to federal candidates' campaigns
- BForeign corporations operating in the United States have the same campaign speech rights as domestic companies
- CThe government may restrict the political speech of corporations when the speech might corrupt the electoral process
- DCorporations and unions have First Amendment rights to make unlimited independent expenditures in electionsCorrect
Why D is right
In Citizens United, the Supreme Court held 5-4 that the government cannot restrict political speech based on the speaker's corporate identity. The Court overruled prior precedents and held that corporations and unions have First Amendment rights to spend unlimited amounts on independent expenditures — spending not coordinated with candidates. This decision led to the creation of Super PACs. Direct contributions to candidates remain regulated.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Citizens United addressed independent expenditures, not direct contributions to candidates. Direct corporate contributions to candidates remain prohibited under FECA; Citizens United only freed up independent spending.
- B
- The Court did not address foreign corporations; foreign nationals (including foreign corporations) remain prohibited from spending in American elections under FECA's ban on foreign spending.
- C
- The Court rejected the 'anti-corruption' rationale for restricting independent expenditures, holding that independent spending by corporations does not give rise to quid pro quo corruption.
Read the following practice passage.
The Committee for a Stronger Valley raised more than $9 million during the last election cycle, including a single $2 million gift from a manufacturing company and several six-figure checks from wealthy individuals. The group spent nearly all of that money on television and online ads urging voters to defeat the state's incumbent senator. It filed regular reports with federal regulators listing every donor. The group gave no money directly to the challenger, and its staff were forbidden from discussing ad timing or messaging with the challenger's campaign.
Based on the passage, the organization described is best classified as which of the following?
- AA traditional PAC, because it gives capped contributions directly to the campaigns of the candidates it favors
- BA 501(c)(4) group, because it may spend on elections while keeping the identities of its donors private
- CA super PAC, because it raises unlimited sums for independent ads and does not coordinate with any campaignCorrect
- DA party committee, because it coordinates its spending with the nominee it is backing
Why C is right
The passage gives four clues: the group accepted unlimited sums, including a $2 million corporate gift; it spent the money on independent ads for or against a candidate; it disclosed its donors to federal regulators; and it neither gave to nor coordinated with the campaign. Together these describe a super PAC, the kind of group made possible after Citizens United v. FEC and SpeechNow.org v. FEC (2010). A super PAC may raise and spend unlimited amounts on independent expenditures, but it must disclose its donors and may not contribute to or coordinate with candidates. A traditional PAC, by contrast, gives limited contributions directly to candidates and faces limits on what it can receive.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage states the group gave no money directly to any candidate and accepted a $2 million corporate gift, far beyond what a traditional PAC may receive; traditional PACs are defined by limited direct contributions to candidates.
- B
- A 501(c)(4) group can avoid disclosing donors, but the passage says this group filed regular reports listing every donor, and its activity was almost entirely electoral rather than social-welfare work.
- D
- Party committees may coordinate certain spending with their nominees, but the passage says the group's staff were forbidden from discussing ad timing or messaging with the campaign.