Read the following practice passage.
Observers often credit sitting members of Congress themselves for their remarkable reelection record, pointing to the newsletters they mail home and the favors their offices perform for constituents. These explanations overlook who actually runs against incumbents. State legislators, mayors, and other experienced politicians calculate their odds carefully, and most decline to risk their careers against an entrenched member; they wait instead for a seat to open through retirement. As a result, incumbents usually face opponents with little name recognition and thin bank accounts, and donors, sensing a lopsided race, keep their money away. The lopsided totals look like devotion to the incumbent, but they mostly reflect contests that never truly begin.
The author of the passage would most likely agree with which of the following statements about the incumbency advantage?
- AIncumbents win chiefly because the casework their offices perform builds a personal loyalty that challengers cannot match
- BReelection rates would likely fall if more experienced officeholders were willing to run against sitting membersCorrect
- CPartisan redistricting by state legislatures is the main reason so few congressional races are competitive
- DRestricting members' use of franked mail would substantially narrow the electoral gap between incumbents and challengers
Why B is right
The passage argues that incumbents' high reelection rates come mainly from the weakness of the people who run against them: experienced politicians (state legislators, mayors) avoid challenging sitting members and wait for open seats, leaving incumbents to face little-known, underfunded opponents whom donors ignore. If more experienced officeholders were willing to challenge incumbents, the author's logic implies reelection rates would drop, so B is the statement the author would endorse. Casework, franked mail, and redistricting are all real sources of the incumbency advantage in course terms, but the author either explicitly downplays them ("the newsletters they mail home and the favors their offices perform" are explanations that "overlook" the real cause) or never discusses them.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Casework is a real source of incumbency advantage, but the passage treats 'the favors their offices perform' as an explanation that overlooks the real cause (weak challengers), so the author would reject 'chiefly'.
- C
- Redistricting does reduce competitiveness in course terms, but the passage never mentions it; the author attributes uncompetitive races to experienced challengers declining to run, not to district lines.
- D
- The franking privilege is a real incumbent advantage, but the author dismisses 'the newsletters they mail home' as a misleading explanation, so the author would not expect limiting franked mail to change outcomes much.