The Three-Fifths Compromise at the Constitutional Convention determined that enslaved people would be counted as three-fifths of a person for purposes of
- ARepresentation in the Electoral College only, not congressional apportionment
- BTaxation only, with no effect on congressional representation
- CBoth congressional representation (apportioning House seats) and direct taxationCorrect
- DDetermining which states qualified for equal representation in the Senate
Why C is right
The Three-Fifths Compromise (Article I, Section 2) counted enslaved persons as three-fifths of a person for two interrelated purposes: apportioning House of Representatives seats among states (giving slaveholding states more representatives by counting their enslaved population) and apportioning direct taxes. The compromise gave southern slaveholding states disproportionate representation in the House and Electoral College, providing political advantages that antislavery delegates resented. The Fourteenth Amendment (Section 2) eliminated this provision after the Civil War.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while the Electoral College followed House apportionment (which was affected by the Three-Fifths Compromise), the compromise was specifically stated in terms of House apportionment and direct taxes, not Electoral College allocation directly.
- B
- Incorrect because the Three-Fifths Compromise applied to both taxation and representation; it was explicitly tied to House apportionment, which was the primary political concern of southern delegates seeking to maximize their congressional and Electoral College representation.
- D
- Incorrect because Senate representation was determined by the Great Compromise (two senators per state regardless of population); the Three-Fifths Compromise addressed House apportionment and taxation, not Senate membership.
Read the following practice passage, which describes a delegate's argument at the Constitutional Convention.
A delegate from a populous state argues that the people, not the state governments, are the true source of the new national government's authority. If a state with ten times as many inhabitants as its smallest neighbor receives the same voice, then the votes of some citizens count for far less than the votes of others. At least one chamber of the national legislature should therefore be chosen directly by the people, and each state's share of seats in that chamber should rise or fall with the number of its inhabitants. Only then, the delegate concludes, will national laws reflect the will of the governed.
The delegate's argument most directly supports which feature of the Constitution?
- AA Senate in which each state has two members chosen by its state legislature
- BA single-chamber Congress in which every state casts one equal vote
- CA system in which state legislatures choose the members of both chambers of Congress
- DA House of Representatives elected directly by the people, with seats apportioned among the states by populationCorrect
Why D is right
The passage makes two claims. First, authority comes from the people, so at least one chamber should be chosen directly by them. Second, a state's share of seats should rise or fall with its number of inhabitants. Both claims match the House of Representatives in Article I, Section 2: members are elected by the people every two years, and seats are apportioned among the states by population. This was the Virginia Plan principle that survived the Great Compromise. The passage does not support the Senate's equal representation, the Articles' one-state-one-vote Congress, or state legislatures choosing members of both chambers, because each of these gives states equal weight or cuts the people's direct role.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Equal state representation in the Senate, with senators originally chosen by state legislatures, was the small-state position (New Jersey Plan, adopted in the Great Compromise). It is exactly what the delegate objects to: giving a large state and a small state the same voice.
- B
- A unicameral legislature with one vote per state describes the Articles of Confederation and the New Jersey Plan. The passage argues against equal state votes because they make some citizens' votes count for less.
- C
- Having state legislatures choose members of both chambers contradicts the passage's claim that the people, not state governments, are the source of authority, and its call for one chamber chosen directly by the people.
Baker v. Carr (1962) was significant in the area of legislative apportionment because the Supreme Court ruled that:
- AStates must redraw legislative districts after every decennial census to account for population changes
- BRacial gerrymandering in state legislative districts was unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause
- CCongressional districts must have roughly equal populations, establishing 'one person, one vote' for federal elections
- DFederal courts had jurisdiction to hear challenges to state legislative apportionment under the Equal Protection ClauseCorrect
Why D is right
Baker v. Carr held that legislative apportionment cases are justiciable (courts can hear them), overruling earlier decisions that apportionment was a nonjusticiable 'political question.' This opened federal courts to apportionment challenges. The 'one person, one vote' standard for state legislative districts was then established in Reynolds v. Sims (1964).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Baker v. Carr did not require post-census redistricting; it ruled courts could hear apportionment challenges, leaving the remedy to subsequent cases.
- B
- Incorrect because racial gerrymandering was addressed in Shaw v. Reno (1993); Baker v. Carr concerned general population-based apportionment, not specifically racial issues.
- C
- Incorrect because 'one person, one vote' for congressional districts came from Wesberry v. Sanders (1964); Baker v. Carr established justiciability, not the specific population standard.