The table shows hypothetical data for one metropolitan area over a single year: the average number of crime stories per week on local evening newscasts, the percentage of residents naming crime as the most important problem facing the community, and the reported crime rate.
| Month | Crime stories per week | % naming crime most important problem | Reported crimes per 1,000 residents |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | 4 | 5 | 42 |
| March | 6 | 7 | 41 |
| May | 11 | 13 | 40 |
| July | 15 | 19 | 39 |
| September | 9 | 12 | 39 |
| November | 5 | 7 | 38 |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- APublic concern about crime was highest in the month with the highest reported crime rate.
- BPublic concern about crime peaked in the same month as crime coverage.Correct
- CEvening news crime coverage was highest in the month with the highest reported crime rate.
- DCrime coverage and public concern both declined steadily from January to November.
Why B is right
In the table, crime stories per week and the share of residents naming crime as the most important problem rise and fall together. Both peak in July (15 stories, 19%). Meanwhile, the reported crime rate falls steadily from 42 to 38. Public concern follows how much coverage crime gets, not how much crime there actually is. That is the agenda-setting function of the media: by deciding how much attention an issue gets, the media shape which issues citizens see as important. The table supports only the claim that concern and coverage peaked in the same month (July).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The highest reported crime rate (42) occurs in January, when only 5% named crime the most important problem, the lowest concern in the table. Public concern peaked in July (19%), when the crime rate was lower (39).
- C
- Coverage was lowest (4 stories per week) in January, the month with the highest crime rate. It peaked in July (15 stories), when the crime rate was lower. This choice reads the coverage column against the wrong row.
- D
- Both coverage and concern rose from January through July and then fell. Neither one declined steadily. This choice misreads the trend by comparing only the end points loosely and ignoring the rise in the middle of the year.
The phenomenon of 'partisan media selective exposure' most directly challenges which earlier assumption about how mass media affects political behavior?
- AThe belief that print media is more politically influential than broadcast media because reading demands more active attention
- BThe agenda-setting theory's assumption that people passively absorb whichever topics the media covers, without any selective engagementCorrect
- CThe 'minimal effects' hypothesis, which held that media rarely changed political views because audiences filter what they consume
- DThe assumption that media owners directly control the political opinions expressed by their journalists and reporters
Why B is right
Classical agenda-setting theory assumed relatively uniform media exposure — that people are exposed to a common media agenda and absorb its priorities. Partisan media selective exposure — the documented tendency of individuals to preferentially consume media that confirms their political beliefs — complicates agenda-setting by showing people curate their information environment. Different partisan groups may therefore develop different 'agendas' (issue priorities) depending on which partisan media they consume, undermining the shared-agenda premise. This also challenges any model assuming citizens share a common information environment.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the print-vs-broadcast influence comparison is a media format debate unrelated to selective exposure; selective exposure occurs across all media formats and the pattern is medium-independent.
- C
- Incorrect because the minimal effects hypothesis actually incorporated selective exposure and attention as reasons why media had limited persuasion effects; selective exposure was part of the minimal effects model, not something that challenges it.
- D
- Incorrect because media owner content control describes a media bias theory unrelated to the selective exposure phenomenon; the challenge posed by selective exposure concerns how audiences use media, not how owners control editorial content.