The table shows hypothetical data on the number of laws enacted by Congress and the number of final rules issued by federal agencies in selected years.
| Year | Laws enacted by Congress | Final rules issued by federal agencies |
|---|---|---|
| 1990 | 650 | 4,300 |
| 2000 | 580 | 4,400 |
| 2010 | 380 | 4,250 |
| 2020 | 300 | 4,200 |
Which of the following is best supported by the data in the table, and which constitutional concern does it most directly raise?
- AAgencies issue far more rules than Congress enacts laws, and the gap widens over time, raising nondelegation concerns about whether Congress gives agencies an intelligible principleCorrect
- BCongress enacted more laws than agencies issued rules in each year shown, suggesting that the Necessary and Proper Clause restrains agency rulemaking
- CAgency rules increased steadily in each year shown, suggesting that the Administrative Procedure Act forbids broad delegations of power to agencies
- DAgency rulemaking fell after 2000, suggesting that the major questions doctrine has ended Congress's practice of delegating rulemaking to agencies
Why A is right
The table shows agencies issuing several thousand rules a year while Congress enacts only a few hundred laws. The gap widens over time both in absolute terms (from 3,650 in 1990 to 3,900 in 2020) and as a ratio (from about 6.6 to 1 to about 14 to 1). Because much binding policy is made by agencies under delegated authority, the data raise the nondelegation concern: under the nondelegation doctrine, Congress may delegate rulemaking power only if the statute supplies an intelligible principle that guides and limits agency discretion. The major questions doctrine is a related but narrower rule for agency actions of vast economic or political significance, and it is not what the data show.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Misreads the table: agencies issued roughly 6 to 14 times as many rules as Congress enacted laws in every year shown. The Necessary and Proper Clause concerns Congress's implied powers, not limits on agency rulemaking.
- C
- Misreads the table: agency rules rose only slightly from 1990 to 2000 and then fell in 2010 and 2020. The APA is a statute that sets rulemaking procedures; it does not forbid broad delegations.
- D
- Rules did fall slightly after 2000, but they still far exceed the number of laws, so delegated rulemaking clearly continues. The major questions doctrine (2022) postdates the data and requires clear authorization only for rules of vast significance; it did not end delegation.
The 'delegation of authority' problem in administrative law arises because Congress often passes broadly worded statutes leaving key policy decisions to agencies. The major questions doctrine, invoked in West Virginia v. EPA (2022), requires which of the following?
- ACongress must explicitly name each industry an agency may regulate whenever a rule touches on greenhouse gas emissions or climate policy
- BAgency rules that cost more than $100 million annually must receive specific legislative authorization from Congress
- CAgencies must apply strict scrutiny to major regulations to ensure they serve compelling governmental interests
- DFor decisions of vast economic and political significance, agencies need clear congressional authorization for that specific actionCorrect
Why D is right
The major questions doctrine holds that when an agency claims authority to take regulatory actions of vast economic and political significance, courts will require clear congressional authorization for that specific action — not just a plausible textual reading. In West Virginia v. EPA, the Court applied this to limit EPA's authority to restructure the electricity grid under Clean Air Act provisions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The doctrine imposes no industry-by-industry or emissions-specific authorization requirement; it governs assertions of broad new authority in any policy domain, not just greenhouse gases or climate.
- B
- The $100 million figure is the threshold for a 'significant regulatory action' triggering OIRA/OMB review under Executive Order 12866, not the trigger for the major questions doctrine.
- C
- Strict scrutiny is a tier of constitutional rights review; the major questions doctrine is a statutory-interpretation canon requiring clear congressional authorization, not a compelling-interest test.
The concept of 'statutory interpretation' requires courts to give meaning to ambiguous congressional language. Which doctrine, recently overturned by the Supreme Court in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (2024), had required courts to defer to agencies' reasonable interpretations of their own enabling statutes?
- AThe Skidmore doctrine, requiring courts to give persuasive weight to agency expertise in fact-finding
- BThe Marbury doctrine, granting courts final authority to interpret the Constitution and review legislative acts
- CThe Chevron doctrine, requiring courts to defer to an agency's reasonable reading of an ambiguous statuteCorrect
- DThe Auer doctrine, directing courts to defer to an agency's reading of its own ambiguous regulations
Why C is right
The Chevron doctrine (from Chevron U.S.A. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, 1984) required courts to defer to an agency's reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous statute it administers, if Congress had not addressed the precise question. The Supreme Court overruled Chevron in Loper Bright (2024), returning interpretive authority to courts.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Skidmore doctrine gives agencies persuasive (not binding) weight in fact-finding; it predates and survived Loper Bright as a more limited deference principle.
- B
- The Marbury doctrine concerns judicial review — the courts' authority over constitutional questions and the validity of legislative acts — a distinct matter from statutory-interpretation deference to agencies; Loper Bright addressed statutory, not constitutional, interpretation and left Marbury untouched.
- D
- Auer deference applies to agencies' interpretations of their own regulations; Chevron deference applied to interpretations of the underlying statutes — a different level of the regulatory hierarchy.