Racial gerrymandering: Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections and Shaw v. Reno
The following is a hypothetical case written for practice.
After the 2020 census, the legislature of the state of Westland drew a new map of its congressional districts. One new district, District 9, linked Latino neighborhoods in two cities about 90 miles apart. In the stretch between the cities, the district was in places no wider than a single highway. Emails between the mapmakers showed that they moved voters in and out of District 9 mainly by ethnicity. They did not rely on county lines, compactness or keeping towns whole. A group of voters living in District 9 sued. They argued that the state had sorted them by ethnicity without good reason.
In Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections (2024), the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 for the voters. The majority held that race or ethnicity was the main factor in drawing District 9. It said such a district must pass strict scrutiny. Westland had not shown that the district was narrowly tailored to serve a compelling government interest, so the district was struck down.
- (A)Identify the constitutional clause that is common to both Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections (2024) and Shaw v. Reno (1993). [1 pt]
- (B)Explain how the facts of Shaw v. Reno and the facts of Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections led to similar holdings. [2 pts]
- (C)Describe an action the Westland state legislature could take in response to the holding in Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections, and explain how that action relates to the holding. [1 pt]