Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Concept Application question

3 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The Concept Application question is Question 1 of the free-response section. You get a short scenario, usually one or two paragraphs, which might be an invented news story, a description of a policy fight, or a situation in a state legislature or in Congress. You then answer three parts, A, B and C, and each part is worth 1 point, so the whole question is worth 3 raw points.

On this page · 6 sections

The free-response section is 100 minutes for four questions and counts for 50% of your exam score. The four question types are Concept Application (3 points), Quantitative Analysis (4 points), SCOTUS Comparison (4 points) and the Argument Essay (6 points). Concept Application has the fewest raw points, but the four questions are weighted equally in the final score. Plan to spend about 20 minutes on it, and do not rush it just because it looks short.

The parts follow a pattern. Part A usually asks you to describe a political institution, behavior or process tied to the scenario. Part B asks you to explain how that concept affects, or is affected by, something in the scenario. Part C asks you to connect the scenario to a different institution or process, such as how another branch could respond.

Readers score each part on its own. There is no thesis and no essay structure, and each point is either earned or not, with no partial credit. Two rules decide most points. First, the task verb matters. "Describe" needs real detail, not just a label. "Explain" needs a because or a how, a chain of cause and effect. Second, the answer must use the scenario, because a correct textbook definition that ignores the scenario often fails Part B or C.

The scenario can come from any of the five course units, so do not assume Question 1 is always about Congress, the presidency or elections. A federalism scenario might describe a state legalizing something that federal law still bans, and then ask you to explain how the national government could respond using the supremacy clause or conditions attached to federal grants. A civil liberties scenario might describe a public school disciplining a student for an online post, and then ask you to explain which constitutional protection is involved and how the courts would weigh it against the school's interest in order. For that school case, Part A might ask you to describe the First Amendment's protection of free speech. Part B might ask how posting off campus affects the school's power to punish, and Part C how a court ruling could limit what other schools do. The practice prompts below come from the legislative and electoral units, but the same three-part method works on every one of these topics.

The rubric, in plain terms

3 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Part A: describe the concept1 pt

Gives an accurate description of the institution, power or process named in the question that shows how it works, not just what it is called or what it is for. For the filibuster, that means the mechanism: senators use the Senate's tradition of unlimited debate to keep a bill from reaching a final vote. Naming the term, stating its purpose alone, or restating the question's words does not earn the point.

Part B: explain the effect in the scenario1 pt

Explains how the concept or action the Part B question names affects an outcome in the scenario, using a specific detail from the stimulus. The answer must show the cause-and-effect link, not just say that an effect exists.

Part C: connect to another institution or process1 pt

Explains how the scenario connects to the second institution, power or behavior the question names, such as a check another branch could use. The answer must say how that institution would act and why it would change the result.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

A stalled bill and a presidential tour

The House has passed a bill to pay for high-speed internet in rural counties. In the Senate, the bill has 54 supporters. A group of senators has announced a filibuster. The majority leader says he cannot bring the bill to a final vote.

The president then spends two weeks traveling to six states whose senators oppose the bill. At each stop she gives a televised speech. She tells crowds that rural families are being left behind, and she asks them to call their senators. White House aides also hint that if the bill stays stuck, the president may sign an executive order directing the Department of Agriculture to shift existing grant money toward rural internet projects.

  1. (A)Describe the filibuster as it is used in the Senate. [1 pt]
  2. (B)In the context of the scenario, explain how the president's speaking tour could affect the bill's chances of passing the Senate. [1 pt]
  3. (C)In the context of the scenario, explain how Congress could check the president if she issues the executive order described. [1 pt]
Prompt 2

A third-party candidate in a House district

In a recent election for a House seat, three candidates ran. The Democratic candidate won 44% of the vote. The Republican candidate won 42%. A candidate from the small Clean Water Party won 14%. The Democrat took the seat.

After the election, some Republican voters said the Clean Water candidate had acted as a spoiler. Clean Water Party leaders pointed out that their party won about 12% of the vote across the whole state but holds no seats in Congress. Two years later, the Republican Party in that state added a strong clean-water plank to its own platform. In the next election for that same House seat, the Clean Water candidate won only 3% of the vote.

  1. (A)Describe the single-member district plurality system used to elect members of the House. [1 pt]
  2. (B)In the context of the scenario, explain how the single-member district plurality system helps explain why the Clean Water Party holds no seats. [1 pt]
  3. (C)In the context of the scenario, explain how the actions of a major political party can limit the long-term success of third parties. [1 pt]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

A stalled bill and a presidential tour · high-scoring response3/3

A. A filibuster is when senators keep debate going on a bill so it never comes to a final vote. The Senate has unlimited debate, so a minority can stall a bill. To end the filibuster you need cloture, which takes 60 votes. That is why the bill is stuck with only 54 supporters even though that is a majority.

B. The president is "going public." She is using TV speeches to appeal straight to voters in states whose senators oppose the bill. If those voters call and pressure their senators, the senators may worry about losing their next election. A few of them might switch and vote for cloture. She only needs six more votes to reach 60, so moving senators in those six states could let the bill reach a final vote and pass.

C. Congress controls the power of the purse. If the president orders the Department of Agriculture to move grant money, Congress could pass an appropriations bill that says that money can only be spent on its original purpose. That would block the order from being carried out. The president could veto it, but Congress could override with two-thirds of both houses.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. Describes how the filibuster works (extended debate blocks a final vote) and adds the 60-vote cloture rule, which goes beyond naming the term.
1/1B — Earned. Identifies the tactic as going public and explains the mechanism: mass appeal, constituent pressure, electoral fear, changed cloture votes. Uses the scenario's 54 votes and six states.
1/1C — Earned. Names a real congressional check, the power of the purse, and explains how a spending restriction would stop the order. The veto-override detail is accurate but not required. In this scenario a majority of Congress supports rural broadband, so blocking the order is politically unlikely. That does not matter here. The question asks what Congress could do, so any constitutionally valid check earns the point. Another accepted answer is passing a statute that overrides or cancels the executive order, with a two-thirds override if the president vetoes it. Oversight hearings can also earn the point if the answer explains how they would check the order. For example, hearings could investigate the shift of grant money and create public and political pressure that leads the agency or president to reverse it. Hearings could also lead to new legislation or a funding restriction.
A stalled bill and a presidential tour · mid-scoring response1/3

A. The filibuster is a tactic senators use to delay a bill. It is a way for the minority party to have power in the Senate.

B. The president's tour could help the bill because she is using her influence. She can meet with senators from those states and make deals with them, like promising support for projects in their state, so they vote for the bill. That is called going public.

C. Congress could check the president by refusing to fund the executive order. Congress has the power of the purse, so it could pass a law that says the Department of Agriculture cannot use the grant money for internet projects. Then the agency would not have the money to follow the order.

How it scored

0/1A — Not earned. "A tactic senators use to delay a bill" gives the filibuster's purpose, not how it works, and the rubric asks for the mechanism. A full description says that senators refuse to end debate, or just threaten to. The bill then cannot reach a final vote unless 60 senators vote for cloture.
0/1B — Not earned. The response confuses going public with bargaining. Meeting senators and trading favors is legislative deal-making. Going public means appealing to the mass public so voters pressure Congress. The scenario describes televised speeches, which the response ignores.
1/1C — Earned. Correctly uses the power of the purse and explains how a funding limit would stop the agency from carrying out the order.
A third-party candidate in a House district · high-scoring response3/3

A. In a single-member district plurality system, each district elects only one representative. The candidate with the most votes wins, even without a majority. Everyone else gets nothing, so it is winner-take-all.

B. The Clean Water Party got about 12% of the vote statewide, but its 12% is spread across the state, so it does not finish first in any district. A party only gets a seat if it finishes first in a district. In this race its candidate got 14%, far behind 44% and 42%. Under proportional representation 12% might win some seats, but here it wins none. Voters also know this, so many vote for a major party instead so their vote is not wasted.

C. Major parties can take over a third party's main issue. The Republicans added a clean-water plank to their platform. Clean Water voters who care most about that issue could now vote Republican and actually have a chance of winning. That is why the Clean Water candidate's share in that district dropped from 14% to 3%. When a major party absorbs the issue, the third party loses the reason it existed.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. Describes both features: one winner per district and plurality (most votes, not a majority) wins.
1/1B — Earned. Explains why votes do not turn into seats (you must finish first in a district) and uses the 12% and 14% figures. It also sees why spread-out support matters: seats are won one district at a time, so a party that polls 12% everywhere but leads nowhere wins nothing. The strategic-voting sentence strengthens it.
1/1C — Earned. Explains co-optation of the issue and ties it to the drop from 14% to 3% in the same House district.
A third-party candidate in a House district · mid-scoring response2/3

A. Single-member district plurality means each district picks one person to send to the House, and whoever gets the most votes wins.

B. The Clean Water Party has no seats because third parties do not have enough money. They cannot afford TV ads like the Democrats and Republicans, and they are usually left out of debates, so voters do not hear about them and they lose.

C. The Republican Party added clean water to its platform. This hurt the Clean Water Party because now people who care about clean water can vote Republican, and the Republicans can actually win. So the third party's voters left and its candidate's share in the district fell to 3%.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. Short but accurate: one representative per district and most votes wins.
0/1B — Not earned. Money and debate access are real barriers, but the question asks about the electoral system. The response never explains that only first place wins a seat, so 12% statewide produces nothing.
1/1C — Earned. Explains how the major party absorbed the issue and links it to the candidate's vote share falling to 3%.

Where points die

Writing a label or a purpose instead of a description in Part A, such as "the filibuster is a delaying tactic." Describe means show how it works. Saying what the filibuster is for (delay) is not enough. Say what the senators do: they refuse to end debate, or threaten to, so the bill cannot reach a final vote. Adding what ends it (cloture, 60 votes) makes the answer stronger, but it is not required. One extra sentence of mechanism usually earns the point.

Treating going public as private persuasion, such as the president calling senators or trading favors. Going public means appealing to the mass public through speeches and media. The goal is to make voters pressure their members. Phone calls and deals with individual members are bargaining, a different tool.

Giving a correct fact that answers a different question. For example, blaming third-party failure on money when the question asks about the electoral system. Answer with the concept the question names. If the prompt says single-member district plurality, your explanation must run through "only first place wins a seat." Extra barriers are fine as extra support, never as your only explanation.

Ignoring the scenario in Parts B and C and writing a general textbook answer. Name at least one detail from the stimulus, such as a vote count, a percentage or an action someone took. Then show how your concept changes that specific outcome.

Mixing up the steps of different processes, such as saying the Supreme Court votes on bills or that a bill needs a constitutional amendment. Keep processes separate. Ordinary laws go through committees, both chambers and the president. Courts only review laws after they pass. Amendments follow Article V. Agency rules follow rulemaking.

Naming a check in Part C without saying how it would work. "Congress has the power of the purse" is only half an answer. Add the action (pass a spending limit), and the result (the agency cannot carry out the order).

Score your own response

0 / 3

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.