A sample of n = 10 measurements has a boxplot showing a strong right skew with one extreme high outlier. The researcher wants to test a claim about the population mean. Which of the following is the best advice?
- ARemove the outlier and proceed with the t-test on the remaining 9 observations
- BProceed with the t-test, since t-procedures are robust to any skewness or outliers
- CAvoid the t-test; with n = 10, the skew and outlier violate normalityCorrect
- DUse a z-test instead, since the z-procedure does not require a normal population
Why C is right
With only 10 observations, the t-procedure requires the population to be approximately normal. Strong right skew and an extreme outlier indicate a substantial departure from normality that the t-procedure cannot tolerate at this sample size. The researcher should consider nonparametric alternatives or data transformations rather than applying the t-test to data that violate its conditions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Removing an outlier without substantive justification is not appropriate statistical practice. The outlier may be a legitimate observation, and removing it changes the research question and can introduce bias.
- B
- Incorrect. t-procedures are not robust to any amount of skewness or outliers. For small samples, they require approximate normality. Strong skewness and extreme outliers can produce misleading results.
- D
- Incorrect. The z-test also assumes normality (or large samples via CLT) and additionally requires knowing sigma. Switching from t to z does not solve the normality problem.