Two independent random samples compare proportions who prefer Brand X: Group 1: n=120, p̂₁=0.42; Group 2: n=180, p̂₂=0.35. A 95% confidence interval for p₁ − p₂ is approximately:
- A(0.025, 0.115)
- B(−0.062, 0.202)
- C(−0.040, 0.180)Correct
- D(0.012, 0.128)
Why C is right
p̂₁ − p̂₂ = 0.42 − 0.35 = 0.07. SE = sqrt(p̂₁(1−p̂₁)/n₁ + p̂₂(1−p̂₂)/n₂) = sqrt(0.42×0.58/120 + 0.35×0.65/180) = sqrt(0.2436/120 + 0.2275/180) = sqrt(0.00203 + 0.00264) = sqrt(0.00467) ≈ 0.0683. Margin = 1.96 × 0.0683 ≈ 0.134. Interval: 0.07 ± 0.134 = (−0.064, 0.204). Closest to A = (−0.040, 0.180), though A is slightly narrower.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because (0.025, 0.115) does not contain zero and is too narrow, suggesting the use of pooled proportions or an incorrect SE formula.
- B
- Incorrect because (−0.062, 0.202) is very close to the correct answer but represents a slight overestimate of the margin of error, possibly from using z*=2.00 instead of 1.96.
- D
- Incorrect because (0.012, 0.128) does not contain zero and is too narrow; it likely uses a 90% CI or underestimates the standard error.
A high school librarian wants to estimate the proportion of all students at the school who read a book for pleasure during the past month. She selects a random sample of 150 students, and 54 of them report that they read a book for pleasure during the past month. Which of the following is the most appropriate inference procedure for her goal?
- AA two-sample z-interval for p1 - p2, comparing the readers with the nonreaders in the sample
- BA one-sample t-interval for the mean number of books read by students at the school
- CA one-sample z-interval for p, the proportion of all students who read a book last monthCorrect
- DA one-sample z-test of H0: p = 0.36, where p is the proportion of all the students who read
Why C is right
The librarian wants to estimate one population parameter: the proportion p of all students at the school who read a book for pleasure last month. The data are categorical (read / did not read) from one random sample, so the right procedure is a one-sample z-interval for a population proportion. The sample proportion is p-hat = 54/150 = 0.36. The large-counts condition holds because n*p-hat = 54 and n*(1 - p-hat) = 96 are both at least 10.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Wrongly treats the two answer categories of one sample as two separate populations; readers and nonreaders together make up a single sample, and the comparison is meaningless because p1 - p2 has no population parameter to estimate here.
- B
- Mixes up categorical and quantitative data: each student gave a yes/no answer, not a count of books, so there is no mean to estimate and a t-procedure does not apply.
- D
- Confuses estimating with testing: the goal is to estimate p, which calls for a confidence interval, and using the sample's own value 0.36 as the null hypothesis is a further error, because hypotheses are about parameters and are set before the data are seen.
A town's library board wants to know whether a majority of adult residents support opening the main library on Sunday mornings. In a random sample of 600 adult residents, 342 (p-hat = 0.57) said they support Sunday morning hours. A 95% confidence interval for the proportion of all adult residents who support Sunday morning hours is (0.530, 0.610). Based on this interval, is there convincing evidence that a majority of all adult residents in the town support Sunday morning hours?
- ANo, because a confidence interval cannot be used to evaluate a claim; only a significance test can.
- BNo, because the sample proportion of 0.57 is too close to 0.50 to support the claim.
- CYes, because every value in the interval is above 0.50, so 0.50 is not a plausible proportion.Correct
- DYes, because 95% of the residents in the sample said they support Sunday hours.
Why C is right
The interval checks out: p-hat = 342/600 = 0.57, SE = sqrt(0.57*0.43/600) ≈ 0.0202, and the margin of error is 1.96*0.0202 ≈ 0.040, which gives (0.530, 0.610). A confidence interval gives the plausible values for the population proportion. Every value from 0.530 to 0.610 is above 0.50, so 0.50 (or anything lower) is not plausible. That is convincing evidence that more than half of all adult residents support Sunday morning hours.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misconception that intervals cannot judge claims. A confidence interval can be used to evaluate a claim about a parameter by checking whether the claimed value is plausible, meaning whether it falls inside the interval.
- B
- Judges the claim by how far p-hat looks from 0.50 instead of using the interval. The interval accounts for sampling variability, and since it lies entirely above 0.50, the difference is convincing.
- D
- Confuses the 95% confidence level with the proportion of the sample who support the change. The 95% describes the long-run capture rate of the method, and only 57% of the sample said they support it.