A residual plot for a linear regression of y on x shows a clear U-shaped (curved) pattern. What does this indicate?
- AThe linear model is appropriate, and the residuals are randomly distributed.
- BThere are influential outliers that are distorting the regression line.
- CThe variability of y increases as x increases, violating the equal variance condition.
- DA linear model is not appropriate; the relationship between x and y is nonlinear.Correct
Why D is right
A curved pattern in the residual plot indicates that the linear model is not appropriate for these data. The U-shape suggests that after the linear trend is removed, there is still a systematic nonlinear pattern remaining, meaning a different model (such as a quadratic or exponential) would be more appropriate.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a random, patternless scatter in the residual plot would indicate the linear model is appropriate. A curved pattern is a clear violation.
- B
- Incorrect because influential outliers typically appear as isolated extreme points in the residual plot, not as a systematic curved pattern across all observations.
- C
- Incorrect because increasing spread (fan shape) in the residual plot indicates heteroscedasticity, not a U-shaped curve. A fan shape and a U-shape are different residual patterns.