A residual plot for a linear regression of y on x shows a clear U-shaped (curved) pattern. What does this indicate?
- AThe linear model is appropriate, and the residuals are randomly distributed.
- BThere are influential outliers that are distorting the regression line.
- CThe variability of y increases as x increases, violating the equal variance condition.
- DA linear model is not appropriate; the relationship between x and y is nonlinear.Correct
Why D is right
A curved pattern in the residual plot indicates that the linear model is not appropriate for these data. The U-shape suggests that after the linear trend is removed, there is still a systematic nonlinear pattern remaining, meaning a different model (such as a quadratic or exponential) would be more appropriate.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because a random, patternless scatter in the residual plot would indicate the linear model is appropriate. A curved pattern is a clear violation.
- B
- Incorrect because influential outliers typically appear as isolated extreme points in the residual plot, not as a systematic curved pattern across all observations.
- C
- Incorrect because increasing spread (fan shape) in the residual plot indicates heteroscedasticity, not a U-shaped curve. A fan shape and a U-shape are different residual patterns.
A residual plot for a linear regression shows residuals scattered randomly around zero with no pattern and approximately equal spread. What does this indicate about the linear model?
- AThe r^2 value must be close to 1.0 since there is no pattern in the residuals.
- BThe residuals confirm that there is no relationship between x and y.
- CThe linear model appears appropriate; conditions of linearity and equal variance seem satisfied.Correct
- DThe model is not a good fit because the residuals should follow a clear pattern.
Why C is right
A random, patternless scatter of residuals around zero with roughly constant spread is exactly what we hope to see in a residual plot. It indicates that the linear model is appropriate for the data (linearity condition satisfied) and that the variability of residuals is constant (equal variance condition satisfied).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because r^2 measures the proportion of total variation explained by the model. Residuals can scatter randomly with both small and large r^2 values — a random residual plot is consistent with any r^2 as long as the model form is correct.
- B
- Incorrect because the absence of a pattern in residuals only tells us the linear model fits well. If there were no relationship, the regression line would be nearly flat and r^2 would be near 0, but residuals could still scatter randomly.
- D
- Incorrect because a pattern in the residuals would indicate a problem with the model (such as nonlinearity). A random scatter with no pattern is a sign that the model is appropriate.
A residual plot for a regression of y on x shows that residuals are large and positive for small x, near zero for medium x, and large and negative for large x. This pattern most likely indicates:
- AThe linear model is appropriate; residuals naturally decrease over the range of x.
- BThe observations are not independent of each other.
- CThe relationship between x and y is nonlinear.Correct
- DThere is increasing variance in y as x increases (heteroscedasticity).
Why C is right
A pattern where residuals go from large positive → near zero → large negative as x increases indicates that the true relationship bends downward more steeply than the linear model captures. The linear model over-predicts at high x-values and under-predicts at low x-values, suggesting a nonlinear (possibly curved or diminishing-returns) relationship.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because naturally decreasing residuals over the range of x is precisely the type of pattern that indicates the linear model is NOT appropriate. A good residual plot would show random scatter.
- B
- Incorrect because independence violations appear as temporal or sequential patterns in residuals (e.g., autocorrelation), not as a consistent trend across x-values from positive to negative.
- D
- Incorrect because heteroscedasticity appears as a fan or funnel shape — increasing spread — in the residual plot. The described pattern (large positive → zero → large negative) is a directional trend, not a spread pattern.