A residual plot for a regression of y on x shows that residuals are large and positive for small x, near zero for medium x, and large and negative for large x. This pattern most likely indicates:
- AThe linear model is appropriate; residuals naturally decrease over the range of x.
- BThe observations are not independent of each other.
- CThe relationship between x and y is nonlinear.Correct
- DThere is increasing variance in y as x increases (heteroscedasticity).
Why C is right
A pattern where residuals go from large positive → near zero → large negative as x increases indicates that the true relationship bends downward more steeply than the linear model captures. The linear model over-predicts at high x-values and under-predicts at low x-values, suggesting a nonlinear (possibly curved or diminishing-returns) relationship.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because naturally decreasing residuals over the range of x is precisely the type of pattern that indicates the linear model is NOT appropriate. A good residual plot would show random scatter.
- B
- Incorrect because independence violations appear as temporal or sequential patterns in residuals (e.g., autocorrelation), not as a consistent trend across x-values from positive to negative.
- D
- Incorrect because heteroscedasticity appears as a fan or funnel shape — increasing spread — in the residual plot. The described pattern (large positive → zero → large negative) is a directional trend, not a spread pattern.