An environmentalist measures mercury levels (ppm) in fish from a lake. A random sample of 20 fish yields: mean = 0.85 ppm, SD = 0.30 ppm. The EPA action level is 1.0 ppm. She tests H0: mu = 1.0 vs. Ha: mu < 1.0 to determine if the mean mercury level is below the action level. The test statistic is t = (0.85 - 1.0)/(0.30/sqrt(20)) = -2.24. With df = 19, the one-sided p-value ≈ 0.019. At alpha = 0.05, what can she conclude?
- AThe test is invalid because mercury levels cannot be normally distributed
- BThere is not sufficient evidence that the mean mercury level is below 1.0 ppm
- CThe mercury level in all fish from this lake is below 1.0 ppm
- DThere is sufficient evidence that the mean mercury level in fish from this lake is below the EPA action level of 1.0 ppmCorrect
Why D is right
The p-value (0.019) is less than alpha (0.05), so we reject H0. There is sufficient evidence to conclude that the mean mercury level in fish from this lake is below the EPA action level of 1.0 ppm. This does not mean every fish is below 1.0 ppm — it refers to the population mean.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because mercury levels can be approximately normal (or the CLT can apply with n = 20 if the data are not severely skewed).
- B
- Incorrect because the p-value (0.019) is less than alpha (0.05), providing sufficient evidence to reject H0.
- C
- Incorrect because the test is about the population mean, not individual fish; some individual fish may still exceed 1.0 ppm.