Two trains move east at 30 m/s and 50 m/s, respectively. What is the speed of the second train relative to the first?
- A20 m/sCorrect
- B80 m/s
- C25 m/s
- D50 m/s
Why A is right
The velocity of the second train relative to the first is v₂ − v₁. Taking east as positive, v₂ − v₁ = (+50 m/s) − (+30 m/s) = +20 m/s. Seen from the first train, the second train pulls ahead to the east at 20 m/s. Because the trains move in the same direction, their velocities partly cancel, so the relative speed is the difference of the speeds rather than the sum. The answer is (A).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Adds the speeds (30 + 50 = 80 m/s). Adding is correct only when the trains move in opposite directions, but here both move east.
- C
- Treats 25 m/s as half of the 50 m/s train's speed, or as some other mix of the two speeds. No correct combination of the two velocities gives 25 m/s.
- D
- Gives the second train's speed relative to the ground (50 m/s). It ignores the fact that the observer on the first train is already moving east at 30 m/s.