Two planets have the same density. Planet X has twice the radius of Planet Y. What is the ratio of gravitational acceleration at the surface of Planet X to that at the surface of Planet Y?
- A8:1
- B1:1
- C2:1Correct
- D4:1
Why C is right
Surface gravity: g = GM/R^2. Mass M = density * volume = rho * (4/3)*pi*R^3. So g = G*rho*(4/3)*pi*R^3/R^2 = (4/3)*pi*G*rho*R. Since g is proportional to R (for same density), g_X/g_Y = R_X/R_Y = 2. The ratio is 2:1.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. This assumes g proportional to R^3, confusing the relationship. The mass scales as R^3 but dividing by R^2 leaves g proportional to R.
- B
- Incorrect. Same density does not mean same surface gravity. The larger planet has more mass and only partially compensates with its larger radius.
- D
- Incorrect. This assumes g proportional to R^2, which would be the case if mass were held constant rather than density.