8 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.
Part A: correct claim with a relevant principle1 pt
States the correct prediction, or correctly agrees or disagrees with the claim, and backs it with at least one physics idea that actually governs the setup. Examples are Newton's second law for the whole system or conservation of energy. A correct claim with no reason, or with a reason that is wrong physics, does not earn it.
Part A: identifies what stays the same and what changes1 pt
Names the specific quantities that matter in this setup and says correctly which stay fixed and which change between the cases. For a rolling race, that means saying both objects start with the same gravitational energy but split their kinetic energy differently. For connected blocks, it means naming the driving force, the resisting force, and the total mass being accelerated.
Part A: complete, coherent chain of reasoning1 pt
Links those quantities step by step to the claim, with no wrong physics anywhere in the paragraph. The reader should be able to follow the cause from the setup to the result without filling a gap. Any incorrect statement, such as saying static friction drains energy from a rolling object, loses this point even if the claim is right.
Part B: starts from a fundamental law1 pt
Begins with a basic relationship written for this situation. That could be the net force on each object set equal to its mass times its acceleration, or the initial energy set equal to the final energy. Starting from a memorized special-case result, such as a formula copied from a textbook example, does not earn it.
Part B: correct substitutions1 pt
Puts the right expression in for every term. Tension is treated as an unknown and not assumed equal to a hanging weight. The normal force comes from the forces perpendicular to the surface. Rotational kinetic energy uses the given rotational inertia, and the rolling condition links angular speed to forward speed as omega = v/R.
Part B: correct final expression1 pt
Reaches an algebraically correct expression for the requested quantity, written only in the symbols the question lists plus physical constants such as g. A misplaced square root, a leftover unknown such as T or omega, or a plugged-in number loses it.
Part C: reads the expression correctly1 pt
Points to the exact variable or term in the Part B expression that controls the comparison and describes its effect correctly. If the variable appears in more than one place, such as both the numerator and the denominator, the response must account for every appearance. A response that only asserts that the expression shows the result does not earn it.
Part C: connects the math to the Part A reasoning1 pt
States whether the expression supports or contradicts the Part A answer and explains why, matching a piece of the math to a piece of the physical story. If the Part A answer was wrong, honestly saying the expression contradicts it, and naming which idea Part A missed, earns this point. A bare statement that it agrees with part A does not.