Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Qualitative/Quantitative Translation FRQ

8 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The Qualitative/Quantitative Translation question, usually shortened to QQT, is the fourth and last free-response question on the AP Physics 1 exam. It is worth 8 points, and because the four free-response questions carry 10, 12, 10 and 8 points, QQT holds a fifth of the section's 40 points. The free-response section counts for 50% of your exam score, which makes this one question worth about 10% of the whole exam. The section runs 1 hour 35 minutes for all four questions. Because 8 of 40 points is 20% of the section, a fair budget for QQT is about 19 minutes, and you should not let the earlier questions eat into it.

On this page · 6 sections

The question tests one skill from three directions: you get a single physical setup, and you have to explain it in words, then in symbols, and then show that the two explanations agree. A typical QQT runs in three parts. Part A asks you to make a prediction or judge a claim about the setup, and it usually tells you to reason without deriving or using equations. Part B asks you to derive an expression in symbols for some quantity. Part C asks you to explain how your expression supports, or contradicts, the reasoning you gave in Part A. Some versions add a short follow-up that asks what happens in a new case, such as a larger mass or a steeper angle.

Part A is a written argument, so readers want a chain of physics, not a slogan. A good paragraph names the principle that controls the situation, such as Newton's second law or conservation of energy. It then says which quantities stay the same, which change, and how that change leads to the result. A bare slogan such as heavier things fall faster earns nothing, even when the claim happens to be right, because it gives no mechanism. Part B is scored the way any derivation is. You must start from a basic law, substitute correct terms, and end with an expression in the symbols the question gives you. Part C rewards one specific move: you point at the place in your Part B expression that controls the answer, and you explain why it agrees with your Part A story.

Readers score point by point, and each point is judged on its own, so a wrong prediction in Part A does not sink Part C. If your Part C correctly reads your own Part B expression, you can still earn those points, even when the expression shows that your Part A answer was wrong. Saying so plainly, and naming what Part A missed, is worth credit. The rubric below models the common 3-3-2 split of points across parts A, B and C. A real exam question may shift a point between parts, but the skills each point rewards stay the same.

The content can come from any unit, but the heaviest units appear most. Force and Translational Dynamics and Work, Energy and Power are each about a fifth of the exam. The rotation material, from torque through rolling and angular momentum, is close to another fifth. Expect pulleys and connected blocks, inclines with friction, springs, rolling objects, and rods on pivots. You may use your calculator and the equation sheet throughout the section.

The rubric, in plain terms

8 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Part A: correct claim with a relevant principle1 pt

States the correct prediction, or correctly agrees or disagrees with the claim, and backs it with at least one physics idea that actually governs the setup. Examples are Newton's second law for the whole system or conservation of energy. A correct claim with no reason, or with a reason that is wrong physics, does not earn it.

Part A: identifies what stays the same and what changes1 pt

Names the specific quantities that matter in this setup and says correctly which stay fixed and which change between the cases. For a rolling race, that means saying both objects start with the same gravitational energy but split their kinetic energy differently. For connected blocks, it means naming the driving force, the resisting force, and the total mass being accelerated.

Part A: complete, coherent chain of reasoning1 pt

Links those quantities step by step to the claim, with no wrong physics anywhere in the paragraph. The reader should be able to follow the cause from the setup to the result without filling a gap. Any incorrect statement, such as saying static friction drains energy from a rolling object, loses this point even if the claim is right.

Part B: starts from a fundamental law1 pt

Begins with a basic relationship written for this situation. That could be the net force on each object set equal to its mass times its acceleration, or the initial energy set equal to the final energy. Starting from a memorized special-case result, such as a formula copied from a textbook example, does not earn it.

Part B: correct substitutions1 pt

Puts the right expression in for every term. Tension is treated as an unknown and not assumed equal to a hanging weight. The normal force comes from the forces perpendicular to the surface. Rotational kinetic energy uses the given rotational inertia, and the rolling condition links angular speed to forward speed as omega = v/R.

Part B: correct final expression1 pt

Reaches an algebraically correct expression for the requested quantity, written only in the symbols the question lists plus physical constants such as g. A misplaced square root, a leftover unknown such as T or omega, or a plugged-in number loses it.

Part C: reads the expression correctly1 pt

Points to the exact variable or term in the Part B expression that controls the comparison and describes its effect correctly. If the variable appears in more than one place, such as both the numerator and the denominator, the response must account for every appearance. A response that only asserts that the expression shows the result does not earn it.

Part C: connects the math to the Part A reasoning1 pt

States whether the expression supports or contradicts the Part A answer and explains why, matching a piece of the math to a piece of the physical story. If the Part A answer was wrong, honestly saying the expression contradicts it, and naming which idea Part A missed, earns this point. A bare statement that it agrees with part A does not.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Two Cylinders Rolling Down an Incline

A solid cylinder and a thin-walled hollow cylinder have the same mass M and the same radius R. The rotational inertia of the solid cylinder about its central axis is (1/2)MR^2, and that of the hollow cylinder is MR^2. Both cylinders are released from rest at the same height h above the bottom of the same incline. Each one rolls down the incline without slipping. Air resistance is negligible.

  1. (A)Which cylinder has the greater translational speed when it reaches the bottom of the incline, or do they have the same speed? Without deriving or using equations, explain your reasoning in a clear, coherent paragraph. [3 pts]
  2. (B)Now consider any cylinder of mass M and radius R whose rotational inertia about its central axis is I = βMR^2, where β is a constant with no units. The cylinder is released from rest at height h and rolls without slipping to the bottom. Derive an expression for the translational speed v of its center of mass at the bottom. Express your answer in terms of β, h, and physical constants, as appropriate. [3 pts]
  3. (C)Explain how your expression from part B supports or contradicts your reasoning in part A. [2 pts]
Prompt 2

A Block on a Table Pulled by a Hanging Block

Block A, of mass m_A, sits on a horizontal table. The coefficient of kinetic friction between block A and the table is μ. A light string is tied to block A, runs horizontally to a light, frictionless pulley at the edge of the table, and holds block B, of mass m_B, which hangs straight down. When the blocks are released from rest, block B moves down and block A slides toward the pulley, both with constant acceleration. A student then replaces block B with a heavier block, leaving block A and the table unchanged. The student argues that the heavier block pulls harder but also has more inertia, so the two effects cancel and the acceleration stays the same.

  1. (A)Do you agree or disagree with the student's claim? Without deriving or using equations, explain your reasoning in a clear, coherent paragraph. [3 pts]
  2. (B)For the original setup, derive an expression for the magnitude a of the acceleration of the blocks. Express your answer in terms of m_A, m_B, μ, and physical constants, as appropriate. [3 pts]
  3. (C)Explain how your expression from part B supports or contradicts your reasoning in part A. [2 pts]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Two Cylinders Rolling Down an Incline · high-scoring response8/8

(A) The solid cylinder is faster at the bottom. Both cylinders have the same mass and start at the same height, so they start with the same gravitational potential energy. They roll without slipping, so the static friction at the contact point does no work and no energy is lost. At the bottom all of that energy is kinetic, but it is split between translational KE (moving forward) and rotational KE (spinning). Rolling without slipping ties how fast each one spins to how fast it moves forward, and both have the same radius, so at the same forward speed they spin at the same rate. The hollow cylinder has all its mass at the rim, so it has more rotational inertia and needs more rotational energy for that same spin. So the hollow cylinder puts a bigger share of the same total energy into spinning and has less left for moving forward. That means the solid cylinder has the greater translational speed.

(B) Energy conservation from top to bottom, with no work done by friction: Mgh = (1/2)Mv^2 + (1/2)Iω^2 Rolling without slipping: ω = v/R. Sub in I = βMR^2: (1/2)(βMR^2)(v/R)^2 = (1/2)βMv^2 Mgh = (1/2)Mv^2 + (1/2)βMv^2 = (1/2)Mv^2(1 + β) M cancels: gh = (1/2)v^2(1 + β) v = sqrt(2gh / (1 + β))

(C) In my expression β is in the denominator, added to 1. The solid cylinder has β = 1/2 and the hollow one has β = 1, so the hollow one has the bigger denominator and the smaller speed. The (1/2)βMv^2 term is the rotational KE, so a bigger β means more of the energy Mgh goes into spinning. That is the same thing I said in part A, that the hollow cylinder's mass at the rim makes it store more energy in rotation, leaving less for forward motion. So the expression supports part A.

How it scored

1/1A1 — Makes the correct claim, that the solid cylinder is faster, and supports it with conservation of energy applied to the whole roll.
1/1A2 — Says the starting gravitational energy is identical for both cylinders while the split between translational and rotational energy differs, which are exactly the quantities that decide the race.
1/1A3 — The chain is complete and correct, and it even explains why static friction removes no energy and why both cylinders spin at the same rate at the same forward speed.
1/1B1 — Starts from energy conservation written for this specific setup, including both the translational and the rotational kinetic energy terms.
1/1B2 — Substitutes I = βMR^2 and the rolling condition ω = v/R correctly, so the rotational term simplifies to (1/2)βMv^2.
1/1B3 — Reaches the correct final answer using only β, h and g, with the square root covering the entire fraction.
1/1C1 — Identifies β in the denominator and substitutes both values, 1/2 and 1, to show which cylinder has the smaller speed.
1/1C2 — Matches the β term to the rotational kinetic energy and connects it explicitly to the mass-at-the-rim argument from part A.
Two Cylinders Rolling Down an Incline · mid-scoring response4/8

(A) The solid cylinder will get to the bottom with more speed. When the cylinders roll down, some of the energy goes into making them spin instead of moving forward. The solid cylinder has less rotational inertia because its mass is closer to the center. Because it has less rotational inertia, there is less friction between it and the ramp, so friction takes away less of its energy as it rolls. More energy is left over for the solid one, so it goes faster.

(B) Conservation of energy: Mgh = 1/2 Mv^2 + 1/2 Iω^2 ω = v/R so 1/2 (βMR^2)(v^2/R^2) = 1/2 βMv^2 Mgh = 1/2 Mv^2 (1 + β) 2gh = v^2(1 + β) v = sqrt(2gh) / (1 + β)

(C) My equation from part B shows the solid cylinder goes faster, which agrees with what I said in part A.

How it scored

1/1A1 — The claim is correct, and it rests on a genuine principle, because the response recognizes that some of the energy goes into spinning.
1/1A2 — Correctly states that the solid cylinder has less rotational inertia because its mass sits closer to the axis, and that the energy divides between spinning and forward motion.
0/1A3 — The chain breaks on incorrect physics. In rolling without slipping, static friction does no work and removes no energy, so the real reason is how the same energy is divided, not a friction loss.
1/1B1 — Starts correctly from conservation of energy, including both kinetic energy terms.
1/1B2 — Substitutes the given rotational inertia and the rolling condition correctly before simplifying.
0/1B3 — The algebra slips on the final line, because the square root must cover the whole fraction to give sqrt(2gh/(1 + β)). Dividing outside the root produces a different, incorrect dependence on β.
0/1C1 — Never identifies which part of the expression matters, since it does not mention β or compare the values 1/2 and 1.
0/1C2 — Offers a bare assertion of agreement with no reason, so nothing in the mathematics is connected to anything in the physical explanation.
A Block on a Table Pulled by a Hanging Block · high-scoring response7/8

(A) I disagree. The acceleration gets bigger with the heavier block. Think of both blocks and the string as one system. The force that drives it is the weight of the hanging block. The force that resists it is kinetic friction on block A, which depends only on block A's normal force, and that doesn't change. So when block B gets heavier, the driving force goes up but the friction stays the same. The student is right that the extra mass adds inertia. But the extra mass brings its own extra weight, so each extra kilogram brings about 10 N of extra force, which is a force-to-mass ratio of g. The system's acceleration is always less than g, because friction resists and block A has to be dragged along too. So the new mass brings more force per kilogram than the system already has, and adding it raises the acceleration instead of canceling out.

(B) Block B (down is positive): m_B g - T = m_B a Block A (toward pulley is positive): T - f = m_A a Vertical forces on A balance, so the normal force is m_A g, and f = μ m_A g. Add the two equations, T cancels: m_B g - μ m_A g = (m_A + m_B) a a = g(m_B - μ m_A) / (m_A + m_B)

(C) In my expression m_B is in the numerator. Making m_B bigger makes the numerator bigger, so a gets bigger. This supports part A, where I said the heavier block makes the acceleration increase, so the student is wrong that the effects cancel.

How it scored

1/1A1 — Correctly disagrees with the student and reasons from the net external force on the whole two-block system.
1/1A2 — Names the driving force, the resisting friction and the added inertia, and correctly observes that the friction force does not change.
1/1A3 — Gives a complete argument with no incorrect physics. The comparison of force per kilogram with g explains why the gain in force outweighs the gain in mass.
1/1B1 — Applies Newton's second law to each block separately, with clear and consistent sign choices.
1/1B2 — Treats tension as an unknown and obtains the normal force from the vertical force balance instead of simply assuming it.
1/1B3 — Reaches the correct expression using only m_A, m_B, μ and g.
0/1C1 — Reads only the numerator, even though m_B also appears in the denominator, and that denominator is exactly the inertia effect the student's claim depends on. The response needed to show that a still rises, for example by rewriting it as a = g[1 - m_A(1 + μ)/(m_A + m_B)], where the subtracted fraction shrinks as m_B grows.
1/1C2 — States that the expression supports part A and connects it to the conclusion that the two effects do not cancel, which matches the correct expression.
A Block on a Table Pulled by a Hanging Block · mid-scoring response4/8

(A) I agree with the student. A heavier hanging block means a bigger weight pulling on the string, so there is more force on the system. But it also means more mass that needs to be accelerated, and by Newton's second law more mass means less acceleration for the same force. Since the force goes up and the mass goes up by the same amount, they cancel out and the acceleration should stay the same.

(B) The tension in the string is equal to the weight of block B, so T = m_B g. For block A: T - f = m_A a f = μ m_A g m_B g - μ m_A g = m_A a a = (m_B g - μ m_A g) / m_A

(C) My expression from part B has m_B in the top and not the bottom, so if m_B goes up then a goes up. This contradicts part A. In part A I thought the extra weight and the extra mass cancel, but the equation shows the extra weight wins, so the acceleration does increase.

How it scored

0/1A1 — Agrees with an incorrect claim, since the acceleration actually increases, so the prediction earns nothing.
1/1A2 — Correctly names the two quantities that change, the driving weight and the total mass being accelerated.
0/1A3 — The reasoning stops at the assertion that the effects cancel without testing it. It also ignores friction, which stays constant and therefore becomes a smaller share of the total.
1/1B1 — Applies Newton's second law correctly to block A as a separate object.
0/1B2 — Sets the tension equal to block B's weight, which would only be true if block B were in equilibrium. Because block B accelerates downward, the tension must be less than m_B g, so tension has to remain an unknown.
0/1B3 — The denominator is m_A instead of m_A + m_B, because block B's inertia disappeared along with its equation.
1/1C1 — Reads the student's own expression correctly, because in that expression m_B appears only in the numerator, so a does increase with m_B. Readers award credit for correctly interpreting your own part B result.
1/1C2 — Honestly states that the expression contradicts part A and identifies the idea that part A got wrong, which earns the connection point.

Where points die

Setting the tension in a string equal to the weight of the hanging block. That shortcut is only true when the hanging block is at rest or moving at constant velocity. If block B accelerates downward, the net force on it points down, so the tension must be smaller than its weight. Leave tension as an unknown, write Newton's second law for each object, and let the algebra cancel it. The same logic decides an elevator question: a scale reading of 24 N on a 20 N object means the support force beats the weight, so the acceleration points up.

Writing the normal force as mg without checking. The normal force is whatever the perpendicular forces need it to be. On a level table with a horizontal string it does equal mg, but you should say why. On a slope with nothing else pressing, it is mg cos(theta), and any push down on the object makes it bigger. Readers want to see where it came from, because friction is mu times the normal force and every later term inherits the mistake.

Writing a Part A paragraph that names a law but never applies it. Naming Newton's second law and then announcing the answer is a label, not an argument. Say which forces act, which of them change, and how that changes the net force or the energy split. A common hidden error is thinking that the force on something follows its speed. Net force sets the acceleration, so constant speed in a straight line means zero net force, and a sliding puck on frictionless ice needs no force to keep going.

Inventing an energy loss, or dropping a condition, in a rolling or equilibrium argument. When an object rolls without slipping, static friction acts at a point that is not sliding, so it does no work. The difference between a hoop and a solid cylinder comes from how they split the same energy between spinning and moving forward. In the same way, a balanced rod or sign needs both zero net force and zero net torque about any axis. Leave either condition out and your explanation is incomplete.

Getting the right physics in Part B, then breaking it in the last line of algebra. The final point goes only to a correct expression, so check the last step slowly before you move on. The usual slips are a square root that covers only part of the fraction, a trig function that flips (tan theta becomes 1/tan theta), or a leftover unknown such as T or omega. Check units, and check a limit that you know: if μ = 0 and m_A = 0, the hanging block should fall at g.

Answering Part C by saying "my equation agrees with part A" and stopping there. Point to the exact symbol that decides the answer, and track it everywhere it appears, both numerator and denominator. Then match it to your Part A story. In the rolling problem, for example, the β term is the share of energy that goes into spinning, which is the same mass-at-the-rim effect your paragraph described. If your expression disagrees with Part A, say so and name what Part A missed. That honest answer still earns points.

Score your own response

0 / 8

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.