A geographer uses GIS to compare organic grocery store locations with socioeconomic data for five neighborhoods in a metropolitan area. The table shows hypothetical data.
| Neighborhood | Median household income | Adults with college degree (%) | Organic grocery stores |
|---|---|---|---|
| North Hill | $95,000 | 38% | 1 |
| Riverside | $62,000 | 61% | 4 |
| Eastgate | $88,000 | 64% | 5 |
| Mill Park | $54,000 | 29% | 0 |
| Cedar Heights | $112,000 | 41% | 1 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- AOrganic store counts rise steadily with median income, as Cedar Heights, the highest-income neighborhood, has the most stores
- BOnly neighborhoods above both thresholds, $80,000 in income and 50% college graduates, contain any organic grocery stores
- CStore counts track college graduation rates more closely than income, since Riverside has more stores than wealthier North Hill or Cedar HeightsCorrect
- DOpening organic stores raised local graduation rates, which explains why Eastgate has both the most stores and the most graduates
- EMill Park has no organic stores because its income is lowest, showing that income alone determines where these stores locate
Why C is right
In the table, the store counts follow the college-degree column. The two neighborhoods with more than 60% graduates (Riverside at 61% and Eastgate at 64%) have the most stores (4 and 5). Higher-income neighborhoods with fewer graduates, North Hill ($95,000, 38%) and Cedar Heights ($112,000, 41%), have only 1 store each. Comparing several variables against store locations in this way is the multivariate spatial correlation analysis that GIS supports, and here it shows education is more closely associated with store locations than income. The data show correlation only, not causation.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This misreads the rows. Cedar Heights has the highest income ($112,000) but only 1 store, while Eastgate has the most (5). Income does not rise steadily with store counts.
- B
- The table contradicts this. Riverside's income is only $62,000 and it has 4 stores, and North Hill and Cedar Heights each have 1 store with fewer than 50% graduates.
- D
- This is an unsupported causal leap. The table shows only an association at one point in time and has no evidence on which variable changed first or why.
- E
- Mill Park also has the lowest share of graduates, so its row cannot separate income from education. The Riverside, North Hill and Cedar Heights rows show that income alone does not predict store counts.