The table shows hypothetical data from a survey in which residents of four towns were asked to describe their hometown. Each response was coded into one category, and each row sums to 100 percent.
| Town | Gave coordinates or a street address (%) | Described position relative to rivers, highways, or cities (%) | Described memories, traditions, or community identity (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| W | 10 | 55 | 35 |
| X | 30 | 40 | 30 |
| Y | 5 | 25 | 70 |
| Z | 45 | 35 | 20 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data?
- ATown Z residents expressed the strongest sense of place, since nearly half of responses cited its coordinates.
- BTown W residents expressed the strongest sense of place, since a majority described the town's position near other features.
- CTown Y residents expressed the strongest sense of place, since most of their responses described meaning and identity.Correct
- DTown X residents expressed the strongest sense of place, since their responses were the most evenly split.
- ETown W residents emphasized location least, since few of their responses cited absolute coordinates.
Why C is right
Location is an objective position in space, either absolute (coordinates, addresses) or relative (position near rivers, highways, cities). Place is a location given human meaning: memories, traditions, and identity. In the table, the third column measures sense of place. Town Y has the highest share there (70 percent, a clear majority), so its residents expressed the strongest sense of place. The other towns' responses lean more toward the two location columns.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Coordinates and street addresses describe absolute location, not place. Town Z has the largest share in that column, so its residents emphasized location most, not place.
- B
- Position relative to rivers, highways, and cities is relative location, which is still location, not place. Town W's 55 percent is the highest relative-location share, not the highest place share.
- D
- An even split across categories does not mean a strong sense of place. Town X's place share (30 percent) is below both Town Y's (70) and Town W's (35).
- E
- This counts only the absolute-location column. Location includes relative location too: Town W's location responses total 10 + 55 = 65 percent, far above Town Y's 5 + 25 = 30 percent, so Town Y emphasized location least.