The table shows hypothetical data on the percentage of households with internet access in Country Z, a country with four regions of equal population, at the national scale and the regional scale.
| Area | Year 1 (%) | Year 2 (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Country Z (national) | 60 | 70 |
| North region | 85 | 92 |
| East region | 70 | 82 |
| South region | 40 | 41 |
| West region | 45 | 65 |
Which of the following conclusions about scale of analysis is best supported by the data in the table?
- AThe national gain of 10 points conceals that access in one region barely changed between Year 1 and Year 2Correct
- BThe national gain of 10 points conceals that access declined in one region between Year 1 and Year 2
- CEvery region gained roughly 10 points, so the national figures accurately describe conditions within each region of Country Z
- DThe gap between the highest-access and lowest-access regions narrowed as national access rose
- EThe region with the lowest access in Year 1 made the largest gain of any region by Year 2
Why A is right
At the national scale, access rose from 60% to 70%, which looks like broad progress. The regional rows show a different pattern. The South rose only from 40% to 41%, a gain of 1 point, while the West gained 20 points and the East 12. So the national average hides a region that was left almost unchanged. This shows that the patterns we see, and the conclusions we draw, depend on the scale of analysis.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- Wrong-direction misreading. No region declined: the South, the weakest performer, still rose slightly, from 40% to 41%. The national figure does hide very uneven change, but not a decline.
- C
- Treats the national average as true of every region. The regional gains were 7, 12, 1, and 20 points, so the 10-point national gain describes no single region well.
- D
- Reversed trend. The gap between the North and the South was 45 points in Year 1 (85 minus 40) and 51 points in Year 2 (92 minus 41), so it widened even as national access rose.
- E
- Wrong-row misreading. The lowest-access region in Year 1 was the South (40%), which gained only 1 point. The largest gain, 20 points, was in the West, which started at 45%.