Read the following practice passage.
A county planning office is preparing two maps for a flood-recovery report. Map X will appear on the report's cover. It is printed at 1:2,000,000 and shows the entire river basin, including parts of three states, the major highways, and the largest cities drawn as single dots. Map Y will be used by crews repairing damaged homes. On it, one centimeter represents 50 meters on the ground, so individual houses, driveways, and storm drains in a single neighborhood can be located by street address.
Based on the passage, which statement correctly compares the two maps?
- AMap X is the larger-scale map, because it covers a much greater area of the river basin
- BMap Y is the smaller-scale map, because its representative fraction is the smaller of the two values
- CMap X is the larger-scale map, because its representative fraction is the larger of the two values
- DMap Y is the larger-scale map, because its representative fraction works out to the larger valueCorrect
- EMap X is the smaller-scale map, because it shows less of the ground area than Map Y does
Why D is right
The passage gives Map X's scale as 1:2,000,000. Map Y's verbal scale (one centimeter represents 50 meters, or 5,000 centimeters) converts to 1:5,000. Because 1/5,000 is a larger fraction than 1/2,000,000, Map Y is the larger-scale map. That fits the passage's description: Map Y shows a small area (one neighborhood) in enough detail to pick out houses and storm drains, while Map X shows a whole multistate basin, with cities drawn only as dots.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Wrong because it makes the common mistake of thinking that 'large scale' means 'large area.' Map X covers more ground, which is what makes it the smaller-scale map (1:2,000,000).
- C
- Wrong because it misreads the passage. Map X's fraction, 1/2,000,000, is far smaller than Map Y's 1/5,000 (1 cm = 50 m), so Map X does not have the larger representative fraction.
- E
- Wrong because, although Map X is the smaller-scale map, the reason is backwards. The passage says Map X shows an entire three-state basin, which is much more ground than Map Y's single neighborhood.
- B
- Wrong because once Map Y's verbal scale is converted to 1:5,000, its representative fraction is the larger value, not the smaller one, so Map Y is the larger-scale map.