The table shows hypothetical data on four minority-language communities in the same country.
| Community | Local jobs requiring dominant-language fluency (%) | Heritage-language use at home, adults 60 and over (%) | Heritage-language use at home, children under 15 (%) | Minority-language broadcast hours per week |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| W | 85 | 90 | 22 | 40 |
| X | 30 | 88 | 74 | 5 |
| Y | 60 | 92 | 51 | 20 |
| Z | 15 | 85 | 79 | 35 |
Which of the following conclusions about language shift is best supported by the data in the table?
- ACommunity X, which had the fewest minority-language broadcast hours, showed the largest generational decline in heritage-language use.
- BCommunity Z had the lowest rate of heritage-language use among children under 15 of the four communities shown.
- CThe generational decline in heritage-language use was larger in each community where a greater share of local jobs required dominant-language fluency.Correct
- DMore weekly minority-language broadcast hours were consistently associated with higher heritage-language use among children.
- EHeritage-language use among adults 60 and over was highest where the smallest share of jobs required dominant-language fluency.
Why C is right
Subtract children's use from older adults' use to get each community's generational decline: W 68 points, Y 41, X 14, Z 6. Ranked by the share of jobs requiring dominant-language fluency (W 85%, Y 60%, X 30%, Z 15%), the communities fall in exactly the same order, so the larger the share of jobs requiring dominant-language fluency, the larger the decline. This fits the idea that economic incentives tied to dominant-language fluency speed up language shift, as families stop passing the heritage language on to their children. Broadcast hours show no consistent pattern: W has the most broadcasting and the steepest decline.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the rows: Community X declined only 14 points (88 to 74), the second-smallest drop; Community W, which had the most broadcast hours, declined the most (68 points).
- B
- Wrong-row reading: Community Z had the HIGHEST children's heritage-language use (79%), not the lowest; Community W had the lowest (22%).
- D
- Unsupported by the data: Community W had the most broadcast hours (40) but the lowest children's use (22%), while Community X had the fewest (5) yet 74% children's use, so there is no consistent relationship.
- E
- Reverses the data: Community Z, with the smallest job requirement (15%), had the LOWEST adult use (85%); the highest adult use was Community Y (92%).