The table shows hypothetical data on the number of speakers (in millions) of four languages, both inside each language's hearth region and outside it, in 1900 and 2000.
| Language | Hearth speakers, 1900 | Hearth speakers, 2000 | Speakers outside hearth, 1900 | Speakers outside hearth, 2000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | 40 | 42 | 2 | 60 |
| Q | 30 | 12 | 0.5 | 18 |
| R | 25 | 26 | 3 | 4 |
| S | 20 | 8 | 4 | 30 |
Based on the data, the spread of which language is best classified as expansion diffusion rather than relocation diffusion, and why?
- ALanguage P, because its speakers outside the hearth rose from 2 million to 60 million while its hearth count held steady at about 40 millionCorrect
- BLanguage S, because the share of its speakers living outside the hearth rose by more than that of any other language
- CLanguage Q, because its number of speakers outside the hearth grew at a faster rate than any other language's
- DLanguage R, because it is the only language whose hearth speaker count and outside count both stayed nearly flat
- ELanguage Q, because the speakers it lost in its hearth were roughly matched by speakers it gained outside
Why A is right
In expansion diffusion, a trait spreads outward while staying strong in its hearth. In relocation diffusion, the trait moves with migrants and the hearth often weakens. In the table, only Language P combines both conditions: speakers outside its hearth grew from 2 to 60 million while its hearth stayed steady (40 to 42 million). Languages Q and S grew outside their hearths, but their hearths shrank sharply (30 to 12 and 20 to 8 million), which fits relocation. Language R hardly spread at all (3 to 4 million outside).
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- S's outside share did rise the most (from about 17% to 79%), but that is because its hearth fell from 20 to 8 million. A weakening hearth points to relocation diffusion, not expansion.
- C
- Q's outside count did grow fastest (36-fold), but its hearth fell from 30 to 12 million. This choice treats the growth rate as the test when the test is whether the hearth stays strong. The pattern fits relocation diffusion.
- D
- R's numbers are nearly flat, but a flat outside count means the language barely spread at all. A stable hearth alone, with no outward spread, is not expansion diffusion.
- E
- Q lost about 18 million hearth speakers and gained about 17.5 million outside. Speakers moving out of the hearth and leaving it weaker is the mark of relocation diffusion, the opposite of expansion.